1907water vs. BodyArmor
A Comparative Analysis of Premium Bottled Water
Choosing between 1907water and BodyArmor can be a challenging decision for those keen on optimizing their hydration. While both brands offer distinct advantages, BodyArmor stands out with its blend of electrolytes, including sodium, potassium, and magnesium, aimed at enhancing hydration during and after exercise. On the other hand, 1907water is celebrated for its naturally alkaline pH level of 8, providing a subtle taste and potential health benefits associated with alkaline water.
Consumers often consider taste, health benefits, and ingredients when selecting bottled water. BodyArmor uses natural flavors and real fruit juice, appealing to those who prefer a slight flavor in their hydration routine. In contrast, 1907water is sourced from a geothermal aquifer, ensuring purity and a high-quality alkaline profile without any added ingredients.
Both brands cater to different hydration needs, making the choice largely dependent on personal preference. BodyArmor is ideal for active individuals looking for electrolyte support, while 1907water offers a naturally high pH level for those interested in the potential benefits of alkaline water. Each has its unique selling points that make them favorable under different circumstances, inviting further exploration and comparison.
1907water and BodyArmor Overview
1907water and BodyArmor are two popular brands offering distinct types of bottled water, each with unique features and benefits. This section explores the histories and product offerings of both brands to help you discern their differences.
Brand Histories
1907water originates from New Zealand. It is drawn from the Kaimanawa Ranges and marketed as natural artesian water. Known for its neutral pH level of around 7.8, 1907water emphasizes purity and minimal processing, ensuring that consumers receive high-quality, naturally sourced water.
BodyArmor, on the other hand, is an American brand known primarily for its sports drinks. The company has ventured into the bottled water market with its BodyArmor SportWater. Founded in 2011, BodyArmor has quickly gained popularity for its focus on hydration and performance, incorporating a blend of electrolytes into its water products.
Product Offerings
1907water is available in various sizes, including 500ml, 1L, and 1.5L bottles. It prides itself on its natural artesian properties, offering consistent purity and taste without additives. With a balanced pH, it caters to those seeking high-quality hydration.
BodyArmor offers SportWater, which is designed with athletes in mind. It contains natural flavors, colors, and a mix of sodium, potassium, and magnesium electrolytes to aid in hydration and recovery during exercise. Typically available in 20oz and 1L bottles, BodyArmor SportWater uses vapor-distilled water to enhance purity and taste, making it an appealing choice for fitness enthusiasts.
Source and Ingredients Analysis
1907Water and BodyArmor SportWater each originate from unique sources and contain distinct ingredient profiles. Understanding these differences can help consumers make an informed choice.
Natural Sources
1907Water is sourced from a natural spring in New Zealand, making its journey through layers of ancient rock and collecting minerals along the way. This process imparts a natural mineral content to the water. The source is renowned for its purity, attributed to the filtering effects of volcanic rock.
BodyArmor SportWater, on the other hand, is prepared from various water sources and is enhanced with added electrolytes. Unlike natural spring water, it undergoes processing to ensure consistent quality and mineral content, enriching it artificially with sodium, potassium, and magnesium.
Ingredient Profiles
1907Water:
Source: New Zealand natural spring
Minerals: Naturally occurring
Additional Processes: Minimal filtration
BodyArmor SportWater:
Source: Varied
Electrolytes Added: Sodium, potassium, magnesium
Taste Enhancements: Natural flavors and colors
While 1907Water maintains a natural mineral composition due to its volcanic spring source, BodyArmor SportWater focuses on hydration benefits through its added electrolytes. Both use natural ingredients, but BodyArmor’s ingredient list is more extensive due to its enhancements.
These differences highlight the variety in bottled water options and emphasize the distinct characteristics consumers might prioritize—natural purity for 1907Water versus electrolyte enrichment for BodyArmor.
Water Quality and Purification Methods
Assessing the water quality and purification methods of 1907water and BodyArmor reveals key differences in their treatment processes and final product characteristics. This evaluation focuses on the specific purification techniques used and the resulting mineral content and pH levels.
Filtration and Purification
1907water utilizes a natural artesian source, which undergoes minimal filtration. The water is often promoted as naturally pure, requiring only basic filtration to remove physical impurities. This process maintains the water's natural mineral content.
In contrast, BodyArmor SportWater employs reverse osmosis (RO) as its primary purification method. RO is a comprehensive filtration process that removes a wide range of contaminants, including dissolved salts, bacteria, and other impurities. This method results in very pure water, almost devoid of all impurities.
While BodyArmor benefits from the extensive purification of reverse osmosis, it may lack the natural minerals retained by 1907water. Consumers choosing between these two brands should consider the extent of purification and the natural mineral content they desire.
Mineral Content and pH Levels
1907water is often characterized by its natural mineral content. Sourced from deep artesian wells, it retains minerals such as calcium and magnesium, known for their health benefits. The water typically has a neutral to slightly alkaline pH, appealing to those preferring naturally balanced water.
BodyArmor SportWater, having undergone reverse osmosis, is initially devoid of most minerals. However, the brand enriches the water with electrolytes and minerals post-filtration. This adjustment not only restores essential minerals but also enhances taste. The pH level of BodyArmor is adjusted to be slightly alkaline, supporting hydration and muscle function, especially beneficial for athletes.
Comparing the two, 1907water offers naturally occurring minerals, while BodyArmor provides added electrolytes tailored for athletic performance. The choice depends on whether one values natural mineral content or enhanced hydration features.
Health and Hydration Benefits
1907water and BodyArmor claim several benefits for health and hydration. Each brand emphasizes unique attributes such as electrolyte content and pH levels to enhance hydration and potential health improvements.
Electrolytes and Hydration Effectiveness
Electrolytes are essential for maintaining proper fluid balance, muscle function, and overall hydration. 1907water contains natural electrolytes, including magnesium, calcium, and potassium. These electrolytes facilitate efficient hydration and help replace lost minerals, especially after physical activities.
In contrast, BodyArmor offers a product called "SportWater" with added electrolytes. It is designed specifically for athletes and individuals with high physical demands. The brand promotes its water as alkaline, with a pH greater than 9, which they claim helps neutralize acid in the body and improve hydration. The effectiveness of these claims may vary, and it’s essential to consider personal hydration needs.
Potential Health Benefits
1907water is sourced from natural, underground aquifers in New Zealand and is praised for its purity. Its alkaline nature, typically around pH 7.8 to 8.2, may support balancing body pH levels, though scientific evidence on these health claims can be mixed. Regular intake of magnesium and calcium from 1907water can support bone health and metabolic functions.
BodyArmor's water focuses on enhanced electrolyte content similar to sports drinks but without added sugars. The inclusion of potassium and magnesium aids muscle recovery and cardiovascular health, making it beneficial for athletes. Its high pH level is marketed to help with acid reduction, which might be an advantage for those with specific dietary preferences or requirements.
Flavor Profile and Enjoyment
When it comes to bottled water, both 1907water and BodyArmor offer unique taste experiences and refreshment qualities. Each brand has its strengths and appeals to different preferences.
Taste Experience
1907water has a clean, crisp taste attributed to its natural artesian source. The water undergoes minimal processing, retaining a pure flavor that appeals to those who prefer a natural and unaltered taste. Some consumers appreciate its subtle mineral presence, which adds to its refreshing properties without overpowering the palate.
BodyArmor, on the other hand, often includes added electrolytes and minerals, enhancing its flavor profile. The blend of sodium, potassium, and magnesium can give the water a slightly more complex taste compared to 1907water. While BodyArmor aims to appeal to those looking for hydration with a bit of added flavor, some may find it slightly more pronounced.
Refreshment Quality
Both 1907water and BodyArmor are designed to be refreshing, but they achieve this in different ways. 1907water stands out for its natural, pure quality. The natural artesian source ensures a clean and refreshing drink, making it ideal for those who appreciate a subtle, crisp refreshment.
BodyArmor incorporates natural flavors and real fruit juice, creating a refreshing experience that is both hydrating and flavorful. The addition of electrolytes aims to enhance hydration, especially after exercise. This can give BodyArmor a slight edge for athletes or active individuals looking for more than just plain water to replenish their bodies.
Nutritional Content and Additives
BodyArmor and 1907water have significantly different nutritional profiles and ingredient lists. The former is fortified with various vitamins and minerals, while the latter prides itself on being a pure, natural water source.
Vitamins and Minerals
BodyArmor is enriched with a variety of vitamins and minerals. Notably, it contains vitamins such as B3, B5, B6, B9, and B12.
It also includes a substantial amount of potassium, providing about 11% of the daily recommended value per 12-oz bottle. This makes it beneficial for athletes needing electrolyte replenishment.
In contrast, 1907water does not contain added vitamins or minerals. It is marketed as natural artesian water. Any minerals present are naturally occurring and include trace amounts of calcium, magnesium, and silica.
Artificial Additives and Sweeteners
BodyArmor's ingredient list reveals the presence of sugar and coconut water concentrate. A 12-oz bottle typically contains approximately 7 teaspoons of cane sugar.
Additionally, it includes natural flavors and preservatives to enhance taste and shelf-life.
1907water is free from artificial additives and sweeteners. It undergoes minimal processing to maintain its natural purity.
This difference may appeal to consumers looking for a simple, additive-free drinking experience.
Environmental and Health Considerations
When comparing 1907water and BodyArmor, it's important to understand their impacts on both the environment and consumer health. This analysis examines eco-friendly packaging and key health concerns, particularly focusing on the materials used and potential contaminants.
Eco-Friendly Packaging
1907water emphasizes sustainability through its use of 100% BPA-free plastic and recyclable materials. This reduces its impact on landfills and minimizes leaching of harmful chemicals into water.
BodyArmor also commits to using BPA-free plastic containers, but it has been criticized for not providing sufficient information on its overall environmental impact. This is concerning given rising consumer awareness of carbon footprints and resource depletion.
While both brands prioritize BPA-free packaging, 1907water appears to take more comprehensive steps in reducing its environmental footprint. Consumers looking for a more eco-friendly option might find 1907water a more appealing choice due to its transparent sustainability practices.
Consumer Health Concerns
1907water sources its water from a spring and emphasizes purity, claiming to be free from contaminants such as heavy metals. It also highlights its natural balance of minerals, which can be beneficial for health.
BodyArmor markets itself as a sports drink alternative, often enriched with added electrolytes and vitamins. Despite these benefits, the use of plastic bottles remains a concern due to potential trace contaminants over time.
Both brands ensure their products are BPA-free, aligning with health guidelines to avoid hormone-disrupting chemicals. Nonetheless, consumers must consider the added ingredients in BodyArmor and the pure spring origin of 1907water when making their choice. While BodyArmor offers enhanced hydration, 1907water offers simplicity and purity, catering to those wary of additives.
Market Availability and Consumer Accessibility
Both 1907Water and BodyArmor are widely available across various retail platforms. They are accessible to consumers looking for different purchase options and offer competitive pricing.
Retail and Online Purchase Options
1907Water is available in major grocery stores, convenience stores, and health food shops. Retail giants like Walmart and Target stock this brand. For consumers who prefer online shopping, Amazon provides a convenient platform to buy 1907Water in bulk, often with subscription discounts.
BodyArmor also enjoys broad retail distribution. Besides grocery stores and convenience outlets, BodyArmor can be found in fitness centers and specialty nutrition stores. Online, it's accessible through Amazon and the official BodyArmor website, offering various packaging options suited for different consumer needs.
Price Comparison
1907Water is generally priced at a higher range due to its premium branding and source from New Zealand. A 12-pack of 1-liter bottles typically costs around $30 on Amazon. This cost includes shipping and potential options for subscription savings.
In contrast, BodyArmor tends to be more affordable. A 12-pack of BodyArmor's 500 ml bottles can be found for about $20 on Amazon. Bulk purchases at grocery stores might offer even more savings, making BodyArmor a cost-effective choice for many consumers.
