How to Score Deer
Expert Tips for Accurate Measurements
Discover > Texas Outdoorsman > How to Score Deer
Scoring deer is a fundamental skill for hunters, wildlife biologists, and outdoor enthusiasts who take an interest in monitoring the health of deer populations. It is a practice rooted in tradition, one that allows individuals to appreciate the beauty and elegance of these magnificent creatures while understanding their vital role in the ecosystem. Accurate scoring of deer provides essential data for tracking population dynamics and making informed decisions about wildlife management.
So, how to score deer? There are numerous scoring systems available, each with its unique approach and emphasis on specific aspects of a deer's anatomy. One of the most widely recognized methods is the Boone and Crockett scoring system, which was developed to standardize the evaluation of North American big game species. This system assesses the size and symmetry of antlers on mature male deer, giving hunters a way to gauge the animal's age, health, and genetic potential.
Regardless of the scoring system employed, the process typically involves careful inspection, measurement, and documentation of the animal's features. By familiarizing oneself with these techniques, individuals can gain insights into the world of deer management and conservation efforts, ensuring a sustainable future for these remarkable animals.
Understanding Scoring Systems
In this section, we will briefly discuss the different scoring systems used by various record-keeping organizations for deer hunting in North America. These systems help hunters compare and assess their hunting achievements objectively and consistently.
Boone & Crockett Club
The Boone & Crockett Club is among the most recognized scoring organizations in North America. Established in 1887, its scoring measurement system focuses on the measure of the antlers' quality. The club uses a combination of various measurements, including:
Number of points
Length of the main beam
Inside spread
Circumference at the base, and;
Distances between the points
Hunters typically use the Boone & Crockett standard when pursuing trophy-sized deer.
Pope and Young Club
The Pope and Young Club is another recognized scoring system in North America. Founded in 1961, it records trophies harvested through bowhunting. The scoring methodology is similar to that of the Boone & Crockett Club, with several criteria to be met:
Fair Chase method: only wild, free-ranging deer, taken following hunting regulations
Minimum waiting period of 60 days after the harvest
Similar scoring criteria as Boone & Crockett (points, length, spread, circumference)
Safari Club International
Safari Club International (SCI) is a global organization that maintains its own scoring system, with a focus on preserving wildlife and hunting traditions worldwide. The SCI scoring includes:
Individual measurements (lengths and circumferences) for each antler
No deductions for asymmetry
Allows for a multitude of different trophies, from North American deer to African and European species
Buckmasters
Buckmasters is a well-known organization among deer hunters in North America. Its scoring system, established in 1994, differs slightly from the others:
Focuses on gross score only (no deductions)
Antler measurements include only the main beam length, points, inside spread, and the sum of abnormal points
Provides a true representation of the deer's antler mass
Each of these scoring systems is respected among hunters and serves their purpose in celebrating the achievements of hunters and the conservation efforts that underpin the sport.
Basics of Deer Scoring
Gross Score Versus Net Score
When scoring a deer, it's important to understand the gross score and the net score. The gross score is the total sum of all point measurement, main beams, and inside spread. Scoring antlers like this represents the deer's antler in its natural state and gives an overall idea of its size.
On the other hand, the net scoring accounts for differences between the left and right antler. To determine this score, deductions are made for unevenness. For instance, if the other antler has an extra point not present on the other side, the length of that point will be deducted from the gross score. The net scoring is often seen as a measure of antler symmetry.
Typical Versus Non-Typical Racks
There are two major categories when you score a deer, typical and non-typical racks. A typical rack is symmetrical, with both sides having the same number of normal point and similar-looking antlers. Many hunters value this classic deer shape for its natural balance and visual appeal.
Non-typical racks, on the other hand, display irregular and asymmetrical antlers. This can include extra points on one side, multiple main beams, or points growing at odd angles. Non-typical racks demonstrate growth abnormalities and can provide unique challenges to score accurately. For example, although rare it's not unheard of for a Whitetail buck to have three main beams.
Typical
Symmetrical antlers
Same number of points on both sides
Non-typical
Irregular and asymmetrical
Extra points, abnormal main beams, or unusual angle points
Understanding Minimum Scores
In deer scoring, there are minimum scores to qualify for entry into record books, such as the Boone & Crockett Club or Pope & Young Club. Such a minimum score is set for both typical and non-typical racks in various categories, depending on the hunting method and deer species.
For example, a typical Whitetail Deer taken with a firearm may have a minimum score of 160 for Boone & Crockett and 125 for Pope & Young. Non-typical minimums could be 185 and 155, respectively. Keep in mind that these numbers are just examples of Whitetail Deer and can vary, so always consult the latest scoring guidelines for accurate information.
It's essential for hunters to be familiar with the minimum scores and measuring methods to properly assess a deer's potential for entering record clubs. This knowledge also helps them make better decisions on whether to take a shot or keep searching for a trophy deer.
Preparation for Scoring
Before scoring a deer, it is crucial to have the proper tools and preparations completed. This section outlines the steps and equipment needed for accurate scoring.
Measuring Equipment Needed
To achieve the most accurate measurements, a variety of tools can be utilized. Here are the recommended pieces of equipment:
Tape measure: A standard, flexible tape measure is essential for taking precise measurements of each part of the antlers. A 1/4-inch-wide, 25-foot-long measure is sufficient for this task.
Steel tape measure: A steel tape measure may be preferable for some hunters, as it offers a high level of durability. This type of measure will also help ensure accuracy in measuring the longer distances found on larger racks.
Folding ruler: A folding ruler provides a straight edge for quick assessment of antler lengths, especially for smaller racks.
Paracord: A sturdy piece of paracord will help in measuring the inside spread of the antlers. It is recommended to have at least 10 feet of paracord for this task.
It is important to choose equipment that is easy to use and accurate. Always keep your tools clean and well-maintained to ensure reproducible results.
Conditioning the Rack
Before scoring the antlers, it is crucial to prepare the rack for accurate and consistent measurements. Follow these steps for proper conditioning:
Air-drying: The first step in conditioning the rack is to let it air-dry for at least 60 days. This will allow the antlers to stabilize and provide a more accurate representation of their size.
Cleaning the antlers: After the drying period, make sure to carefully clean any dirt or debris from the antlers to avoid interference with measurements.
Positioning the rack: Place the antlers on a flat, stable surface with plenty of room for measuring. Ensure that they are positioned naturally and symmetrically to avoid inconsistencies in measurements.
Once the rack has been properly prepared, it is ready for scoring. This process requires attention to detail, patience, and a clear understanding of the various parts of the antlers. By following these preparation steps, the scoring process will be smoother and more accurate.
Scoring the Antlers
To score a deer involves the process of measuring deer antlers, where a series of measurements and calculations arrive at the final score. In this section, we will discuss the different aspects of scoring deer antlers, including measuring the main beam, tines and tip spread, beam circumference measurements, inside spread, mass and H measurements, and subtracting deductions.
Measuring Main Beams
The main beams are the primary support structure for the deer antlers and carry the tines. To measure each main beam length, start at the base, follow the center line of the main beam, and measure to the tip using a flexible measure. Record the measurements of both right main beam and left main beam at the widest point.
Tines and Points
Tines are the individual branches coming off the main beam and are measured as tine length. Points are the sharp, smallest point ends of tines. To score them, count how many tines and measure the total length from their base to the tip to obtain the tine length. For total points, count the number of points on the top edge of each antler that are at least one inch long.
Beam Circumference
The four circumference measurements of the main beam should be measured at different locations:
H1: From the first point G1. The smallest circumference between the burr and the first antler point
H2: The smallest circumference between the first and second antler points
H3: The smallest circumference between the second and third antler points
H4: From the halfway point between G3 and the main beam tip. The smallest circumference between the third and fourth antler points
Measure the circumference at these locations with a flexible cable and record the values.
Inside Spread
Inside spread is the distance between the widest points of the buck's antlers on a horizontal plane. Measure the inside spread using a metal measure, a flexible steel cable or a straight and rigid measuring stick to take four measurements to ensure accuracy.
Mass and H Measurements
Mass measurements are taken at the four H measurement locations discussed earlier in the beam circumference section. To calculate mass, wrap a flexible measure around lowest outside edge of the antler at each H measurement location and record the results.
Subtracting Deductions
Deductions are made for differences in measurements between the right and left antler, as well as for abnormal points. Abnormal points are those that branch off from another point or are non-typical in location or growth direction. To deduct an abnormal point, measure the length of each abnormal point and sum them. Subtract the sum of abnormal points from the score.
Now that you are familiar with all aspects of scoring deer antlers, you can confidently and accurately assess the significance of each point on a deer's antlers using these methods.
Finalizing the Score
Calculating Total Score
To finalize the score of a deer, first, take the measurements you have collected, including the spread, main beam lengths, tine lengths, and circumferences. Combine these measurements using the appropriate formula. The Boone & Crockett score is a popular method that can be used to calculate the score of a deer. The total result includes net scores and any additional deductions. The spread credit also needs to be factored into the calculations. Usually the buck's inside spread does not exceed the longest main beam.
Understanding Deductions
Deductions include any asymmetry between the deer's antlers. Calculate the differences between the measurements taken on the left and right antlers. These deductions are then subtracted from the preliminary score to obtain the final net score which follows the Boone & Crockett scoring requirements. Keep in mind that the net score represents the deer's symmetry and adheres to the standardized scoring system.
Waiting Period and Official Scoring
A green or preliminary score must be determined before submitting the final official score. This involves waiting for 60 days after the deer has been harvested, allowing the antlers to sufficiently dry and shrink. Once this waiting period has passed, an official scorer can be contacted to verify the measurements and assure proper scoring from a rough estimate according to the established guidelines.
By following these steps and familiarizing yourself with the scoring procedures, you'll be able to confidently and accurately score your deer.
Interpreting the Score
Record Book Achievements
When scoring a deer, it is common for hunters to reference the Record Book Achievements to determine if their Whitetail buck is considered a trophy. The Boone and Crockett (B&C), Pope and Young (P&Y) and Safari Club International (SCI) are notable record books. The Crockett Score Sheet and the Young Record Book enable you to track the best typical and non-typical racks using their respective scoring system. Each record book has its established minimum scores for both typical and non-typical racks. For instance:
Score Classifications
Scoring classifications allow hunters to understand whether their buck is considered average, above average, or even a trophy class animal. When scoring a buck, the total number of points, spread width, and antler characteristics are all taken into consideration. Classification consists of these general ranges:
0-100: Average class buck
100-150: Above average class buck
150 and above: Trophy class buck
However, it's important most hunters to note that a good score for a buck can vary based on the region and habitat.
Comparison to Regional Averages
When interpreting the score of your deer, it is useful to compare it to regional averages to have a better understanding of the quality of your animal. The regional averages vary across different areas and can help hunters set personal hunting benchmarks at other points.
For example, a buck scoring 130 would be an exceptional deer in some regions, while in others, a score of 130 might be more common. Comparing your buck's score to the regional average can give you a meaningful perspective on your achievement and help set your expectations for future hunts.
