Eternal vs. Liquid Death

Written By Muhammad Shahid

Which Bottled Water is Better?

Choosing between Eternal and Liquid Death bottled water involves considering factors such as taste, packaging, and health benefits. Liquid Death offers both sparkling and still water options packaged in environmentally friendly aluminum cans, avoiding the BPA concerns associated with plastic bottles. This makes it an attractive choice for eco-conscious consumers.

Eternal water, known for its natural alkalinity and high mineral content, provides a distinct, pure taste, sourced from naturally protected underground springs. Its focus on hydration through high-quality, consistently purified water appeals to those seeking wellness benefits.

Both brands bring unique features to the table, from Liquid Death’s edgy marketing and eco-friendly stance to Eternal’s commitment to purity and natural hydration. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual preferences for taste, health considerations, and environmental impact.

Brand Overview

Liquid Death and Eternal Water have established themselves as prominent names in the bottled water industry. Both brands have unique origin stories and distinct branding strategies that appeal to diverse consumer bases.

History of Liquid Death

Liquid Death was founded by Mike Cessario, a former creative director for agencies working with Netflix and Uber. The brand launched with an edgy, punk-inspired image designed to stand out in the crowded water market.

Liquid Death initially gained traction through viral marketing campaigns and a strong social media presence, especially on Instagram and TikTok. They used their slogan "Murder Your Thirst" to resonate with a younger, more rebellious demographic.

The branding is intentionally provocative, with can designs that mimic energy drinks more than traditional water bottles. Liquid Death is available in both flat and sparkling varieties, and it can be purchased from numerous retailers, including Amazon and Whole Foods.

Eternal Water's Brand Journey

Eternal Water positions itself as a premium, natural alternative to other bottled waters. Known for its naturally alkaline water sourced from protected underground springs, the brand appeals to health-conscious consumers.

The company's branding emphasizes purity and quality. Eternal Water goes through a rigorous filtration process that includes micro-filters, reverse osmosis, and ultraviolet exposure, ensuring 99.9% purity. This process is complemented by the infusion of electrolytes.

Eternal Water’s distribution includes both online platforms and physical stores, making it accessible to a wide audience. Its commitment to providing high-quality, naturally alkaline water has made it a favorite among those looking for not just hydration, but also added health benefits.

Sustainability and Environmental Impact

Both Liquid Death and Eternal have unique approaches to sustainability. Liquid Death focuses on reducing plastic waste with its aluminum cans, while Eternal aims to address the environmental concerns associated with water bottling.

Liquid Death's Eco-Friendly Approach

Liquid Death offers water in aluminum cans, which are infinitely recyclable. This significantly reduces the environmental cost associated with packaging. Aluminum cans are lighter than plastic bottles, leading to decreased fuel consumption and lower carbon emissions during transportation. Their slogan, "Death to Plastic", underscores their commitment to combating plastic pollution.

The brand emphasizes sustainability through its edgy marketing, aiming to attract a younger, eco-conscious audience. By choosing cans over plastic, Liquid Death taps into a market that prioritizes environmentally friendly packaging.

Eternal's Commitment to the Environment

Eternal focuses on using reusable bottles and promoting eco-friendly practices in its production processes. Unlike traditional plastic bottles, Eternal's approach limits single-use plastic waste. They engage in recycling initiatives to mitigate the environmental impact.

Eternal also invests in sustainable sourcing of water, ensuring that their bottled water has a minimal environmental footprint. Their commitment revolves around reducing CO2 emissions during production and using environmentally friendly materials for packaging.

Packaging and Design

Packaging and design play a crucial role in differentiating bottled water brands. Liquid Death uses recyclable aluminum cans with a punk-rock aesthetic, while Eternal Water opts for recyclable PET plastic bottles with a more traditional look.

Liquid Death's Canned Water Innovation

Liquid Death packages its water in recyclable aluminum cans. These cans are notable for their skull and crossbones logo, which evokes a punk-rock vibe.

The branding contrasts sharply with the typically serene and clean look of bottled water, making Liquid Death a standout on the shelf. The aluminum can offers environmental benefits since it is infinitely recyclable and requires less energy to produce compared to plastic.

Moreover, the design has garnered attention in pop culture, appealing to a younger, eco-conscious audience. The edgy packaging isn’t just about looks; it underscores a commitment to sustainability by reducing single-use plastics.

Eternal Water's Packaging Strategy

Eternal Water uses recyclable PET plastic bottles for its packaging. These bottles are clear and emphasize natural purity, often highlighting the water's source. The design is more traditional and less flashy than that of Liquid Death.

Despite using plastic, Eternal Water aims for sustainability. The bottles are made from high-grade PET plastic, which is 100% recyclable.

This approach offers a balance between practicality and environmental responsibility. The branding tends to focus more on the natural and alkaline qualities of the water, targeting a health-conscious demographic.

Product Variants and Offerings

This comparison looks at the diversity of product variants offered by Liquid Death and Eternal Water, covering their still, sparkling, and flavored water options, as well as their unique packaging choices.

Liquid Death's Range of Products

Liquid Death is known for its distinctive marketing and packaging. They offer both still and sparkling water. The water is packaged in 16.9-ounce aluminum cans, which sets them apart from most competitors who typically use plastic bottles. Aluminum is environmentally friendly and recyclable, which appeals to eco-conscious consumers.

The sparkling water variant is popular for its pure taste and is free from additives and flavors. Liquid Death also provides various flavored water options, including choices like "Mango Chainsaw" and "Severed Lime." These are created without artificial additives, focusing on natural flavors. The brand’s emphasis on aluminum packaging and viral marketing campaigns has resonated well with younger audiences.

Eternal's Water Selection

Eternal Water offers a different approach with their product range. Their primary focus is on natural alkaline water. Eternal's water is sourced from naturally alkaline springs and goes through minimal processing, ensuring it retains its natural minerals. The water is typically packaged in high-quality plastic bottles that are BPA-free, which meets safety and quality standards.

Eternal Water provides options in various sizes, including personal and family-sized bottles. Their product range emphasizes the health benefits of naturally alkaline water, making it ideal for those interested in wellness and hydration.

They do not offer flavored or sparkling water variants, focusing solely on the purity and quality of their natural alkaline still water. This emphasis on minimal processing and source integrity appeals to health-conscious consumers.

Quality and Source

Understanding the quality and source of bottled water is crucial for consumers. The source of the water and its purification process significantly impact its taste and mineral content.

The Source of Liquid Death's Water

Liquid Death sources its water from the Austrian Alps. This mountain region is renowned for its high-quality, natural spring water.

The water undergoes minimal processing to preserve its natural minerals, giving it a subtle taste that's free from impurities. Liquid Death's water is available in both flat and sparkling varieties, ensuring options for different preferences.

The water is packaged in air-tight aluminum cans, which helps maintain its purity and prevents any plastic contamination.

Eternal Water's Natural Source

Eternal Water is sourced from naturally alkaline springs in the USA. These springs are located deep underground, providing water that is naturally filtered through layers of ancient rock.

This process enriches the water with minerals like calcium, magnesium, and potassium. Eternal Water boasts a high pH level, often around 8.0, which adds to its smooth, clean taste.

The water goes through a minimal purification process to maintain its natural mineral content, ensuring it remains a healthy choice for hydration.

Health and Hydration Benefits

When comparing the health and hydration benefits of Liquid Death and Eternal Water, it is essential to evaluate their composition and effects on the body. Both types of water provide hydration but have distinctive attributes that may impact their suitability for different preferences and needs.

Hydration Properties of Liquid Death

Liquid Death comes in two forms: sparkling and still. Both types aim to hydrate effectively.

The sparkling version may enhance the drinking experience for some. It's important to note that while the carbonation provides a distinct taste, it does not offer extra hydration benefits compared to regular water.

Liquid Death also offers an electrolyte mix called "Death Dust." This product contains sodium and potassium, which help maintain hydration levels, but also includes sugar.

For consumers looking for a simple, refreshing, and enjoyable way to stay hydrated, both the sparkling and still options of Liquid Death can be considered a healthy option.

Eternal Water's Health Benefits

Eternal Water is sourced from naturally occurring springs and boasts a high pH level.

Higher pH levels in water are associated with alkaline properties, which some believe help balance the body's pH and aid in hydration. Eternal Water's mineral content can help hydrate and replenish the body.

Unlike some other bottled waters, Eternal Water is free of artificial additives. This can make it an appealing choice for those looking for a pure and healthy option.

Additionally, its consistent mineral composition makes it a reliable choice for everyday hydration needs.

Marketing and Consumer Perception

Liquid Death employs a disruptive marketing strategy that embraces edgy and alternative branding, while Eternal focuses on a more traditional, health-centered image.

Liquid Death's Marketing Strategy

Liquid Death stands out with a rebellious and unconventional approach. The brand uses the tagline "Murder Your Thirst!", and its packaging resembles energy drinks or craft beer, featuring skulls and gothic imagery.

Celebrity endorsements, such as partnerships with Travis Barker, amplify its alternative appeal.

The company's irreverent marketing has also involved partnerships with Live Nation and viral video content. By positioning itself against conventional bottled water brands like Coca-Cola-owned Topo Chico, Liquid Death successfully targets a younger, edgy demographic.

This strategy has led to a rapid growth in brand recognition and a strong connection with its audience.

Eternal's Brand Perception

Eternal markets its water as a premium, health-focused option, emphasizing purity and natural sources. The company often highlights the alkaline properties of its water, appealing to health-conscious consumers.

The packaging is sleek and minimalist, reinforcing a sense of luxury and wellness.

Unlike Liquid Death's aggressive campaigns, Eternal opts for subtle marketing tactics, such as influencer partnerships and collaborations with health and wellness events.

Consumers perceive Eternal as a sophisticated and high-quality brand, aligning it with other premium bottled waters like La Croix and Bubly. This health-centric and elegant branding appeals to a different demographic focused on wellness and lifestyle.

Comparative Taste Test

In a recent blind taste test, both Eternal and Liquid Death were put to the test to see which water impresses more.

Eternal offers a clean, crisp taste that many found refreshing. Its smooth mouthfeel and neutral profile make it a favorite among those who prefer their water with minimal aftertaste.

Liquid Death, featuring both still and sparkling water, brings a twist with its bold branding and unique aluminum can. The plain sparkling water offers a lively fizz without any added flavors, catering to soda lovers looking for a healthier option.

In the case of flavored water, Liquid Death has a diverse range. The lineup includes varieties such as their Armless Palmer iced tea and sparkling waters with custom art on each can. Each flavor is crafted with distinctive ingredients, providing a refreshing alternative to traditional sodas.

Here is a quick comparison of key taste features:

Aspect Eternal Liquid Death Taste Clean, crisp Varied (plain, sparkling, flavored) Mouthfeel Smooth Effervescent for sparkling options Aftertaste Minimal Bold with some flavored variations Packaging Plastic bottle Aluminum can with recycling content

Preferences varied with some testers preferring the simplicity of Eternal, while others favored the dynamic offerings from Liquid Death. Both brands succeeded in delivering a unique and hydrating experience.

Pricing and Availability

Liquid Death offers its water in both sparkling and flat varieties. It's available in cans, typically sold as singles or in six-packs. You can find Liquid Death in a variety of places, including 7-11, Whole Foods, Sprouts Farmers Market, and Sheetz. Additionally, it’s available for purchase online through their website and other online platforms like Amazon.

Eternal Water is bottled in plastic and glass containers. It can be found in major grocery stores and retailers such as Target and Whole Foods. Eternal Water is also available for order online through Amazon and the company’s website.

Pricing Comparison

Here is a price comparison of Liquid Death and Eternal Water from popular retailers:

Retailer Liquid Death (per can) Eternal Water (per bottle) Target $1.62 $1.99 Amazon Varies Varies Whole Foods Varies Varies

Both brands often offer discounts for bulk purchases or subscriptions.

Availability in Bars

Liquid Death has targeted bars and music venues as part of its marketing strategy, making it a common sight in such establishments. This availability in bars adds a unique edge for those looking for a non-alcoholic alternative that feels a bit more rebellious.

Eternal Water, on the other hand, is less commonly found in bars but focuses more on a premium grocery store presence.

Sales Channels

Both brands emphasize sales through online channels to complement their physical store availability. This makes it convenient for customers to order directly from Amazon or their respective websites, ensuring a wider reach even if local stores are not stocked.

Consumer Reviews and Testimonials

When comparing Eternal and Liquid Death bottled water, consumer reviews provide valuable insights.

Taste: Many consumers describe Liquid Death's sparkling water as refreshing with a pleasant, prickly texture. Eternal, on the other hand, is often appreciated for its crisp, clean taste.

Branding: Liquid Death stands out with its unique, edgy branding. The brand’s approach appeals particularly to younger consumers and those active on social media. Eternal’s branding is more understated, focusing on purity and health benefits.

Packaging: Liquid Death uses aluminum cans, which some consumers prefer for environmental reasons. Eternal’s plastic bottles are lightweight, but there’s increasing awareness regarding the risks of BPA exposure from plastic.

Social Media: Liquid Death’s bold presence on social platforms has garnered a loyal following. Many users share their experiences and photos, helping to boost the brand’s popularity. Eternal, while appreciated by users, lacks the same level of viral marketing.

Popular Choices: Liquid Death, especially its flavored options like Mango Chainsaw, has received positive feedback for its taste. Eternal water often gets recommended for its smooth, unflavored quality.

Sales & Availability: Both brands have strong sales. Liquid Death's unique appeal and marketing strategy play a role in its widespread recognition. Eternal remains a top choice for those seeking high-quality non-sparkling water.

Consumer Testimonials:

  1. "Liquid Death’s sparkling water is the only one I drink now. Love the aggressive branding!"

  2. "Eternal water feels pure and perfect for my daily hydration."

  3. "I switched to Liquid Death because of the aluminum cans; it's a greener choice."

  4. "Eternal tastes clean and natural, ideal for gym sessions."

These testimonials highlight the preferences and experiences of everyday users, emphasizing the strengths and characteristics of each brand.

Concluding Assessment

Eternal and Liquid Death offer distinct features catering to different preferences.

Eternal Water

Eternal water is naturally alkaline, sourced from protected underground springs. This water is bottled in BPA-free plastic packaging. For health-conscious consumers, its natural mineral composition is appealing.

Liquid Death

Liquid Death offers 100% mountain spring water in aluminum cans, sourced from the Austrian Alps. The brand's eco-friendly aluminum packaging contains 70% recycled material, positioning it as a healthier alternative to plastic bottles.

Eco-Friendly Packaging

  • Eternal: BPA-free plastic

  • Liquid Death: 70% recycled aluminum

Health Considerations

Both brands offer purified water with no additives. Liquid Death's aluminum packaging might score higher in terms of eco-friendliness, reducing plastic waste. Eternal's natural alkalinity and mineral composition could make it a preferred choice for those seeking nutritional benefits.

Brand Availability

  • Eternal: Widely available in grocery stores and online.

  • Liquid Death: Available in select stores like Whole Foods, 7-11, and online.

Consumer Preference

Preference depends on individual values such as packaging sustainability or mineral content. Eco-conscious consumers might favor Liquid Death's aluminum cans, while those prioritizing natural mineral benefits may lean towards Eternal water.

Choosing the better bottled water essentially hinges on personal priorities, whether it's environmental impact, health benefits, or accessibility.

More About Eternal

More About Liquid Death

Muhammad Shahid
Previous

Eternal vs. Mananalu
Next

Eternal vs. Kroger