Icelandic Glacial vs. Mananalu

Written By Muhammad Shahid

Evaluating the Better Bottled Water

When it comes to choosing bottled water, two brands often rise to the top: Icelandic Glacial and Mananalu. Both are touted for their purity and unique sources, appealing to health-conscious consumers. If you're looking for the cleanest and most refreshing option, Icelandic Glacial might be the better choice due to its natural spring origin and balanced mineral content.

Mananalu, founded by actor Jason Momoa, offers an eco-friendly twist by using aluminum packaging, which is more sustainable than traditional plastic bottles. This makes it an attractive option for environmentally-conscious consumers. The water itself is also sourced from natural springs, ensuring a clean and crisp taste.

Both brands provide excellent hydration, but their distinct features cater to different priorities. While Icelandic Glacial focuses on mineral balance and purity, Mananalu emphasizes environmental sustainability without compromising on quality.

What Is Bottled Water?

Bottled water is a form of packaged drinking water that comes in various types and offers convenience and portability. It often undergoes different purification processes and mineral additions to distinguish one brand from another.

Understanding Bottled Water

Bottled water typically starts from one of several sources: springs, wells, or public water supplies. Spring water is drawn directly from natural springs and is often rich in minerals because it passes through rocks. Mineral water must contain at least 250 parts per million of total dissolved solids and is also sourced from mineral springs.

Purified water comes from taps or other sources but goes through processes like distillation or reverse osmosis to remove impurities. This type has fewer minerals compared to spring or mineral water. Alkaline water has a higher pH level, often achieved through ionization, promoting benefits like improved hydration and acid-base balance in the body.

Types of Bottled Water

  • Spring Water: Directly from a natural spring source

  • Mineral Water: Contains significant minerals from its natural source

  • Purified Water: Treated through processes to remove impurities

  • Alkaline Water: Higher pH level, often ionized

Each type serves different consumer preferences and needs, ranging from mineral-rich options to those focused on purity or specific health benefits like higher pH levels. Bottled water remains a convenient alternative for many global consumers.

Exploring the Brands

Both Icelandic Glacial and Mananalu have distinct origins and missions that appeal to environmentally-conscious consumers.

Origin and Brand Ethos of Icelandic Glacial

Icelandic Glacial originates from the Ölfus Spring in Iceland, one of the world's cleanest and most abundant springs. The company emphasizes its commitment to sustainability by using 100% recyclable packaging and being the first bottled water manufacturer to receive a CarbonNeutral® certification for both product and operation.

Their water is naturally filtered through volcanic rock, ensuring a clean and crisp taste rich in minerals. The brand focuses on purity and environmental responsibility, aiming to provide high-quality water while minimizing its carbon footprint.

Origin and Mission of Mananalu

Mananalu was founded by actor Jason Momoa in 2019, inspired by his role in "Aquaman." The brand aims to combat plastic pollution by offering water in 100% recyclable aluminum cans. Mananalu's mission is to eliminate single-use plastic bottles, aligning with a broader environmental ethos.

The water is purified and sourced from various locations, ensuring quality and accessibility. The brand emphasizes activism and environmental stewardship, encouraging consumers to make responsible choices. Through its mission-driven approach, Mananalu attracts those who are looking for both a refreshing drink and a way to contribute to sustainable practices.

Health and Hydration

Icelandic Glacial and Mananalu bottled waters offer different health benefits through their unique pH levels and mineral content, impacting hydration and overall wellness.

pH Levels and Health Implications

Icelandic Glacial water boasts a high alkaline level with a pH of 8.4. Alkaline water is believed to neutralize acid in the body, which may help prevent certain diseases.

Mananalu water also presents a balanced pH, typically around 7.5 to 8.0. While not as high as Icelandic Glacial, it still provides similar potential benefits. Alkaline water can aid in reducing acid reflux symptoms and improving hydration efficiency.

Mineral Content and Hydration Benefits

Both brands of water provide essential minerals that aid hydration. Icelandic Glacial contains low concentrations of calcium (5.7 mg/L), magnesium (2.2 mg/L), and sodium (11 mg/L). These minerals support muscle function and maintain electrolyte balance.

Mananalu water has a comparable mineral profile, though exact numbers are less emphasized. Its mineral content helps replenish electrolytes lost through sweat, making it a viable option for hydration during physical activities.

Table: Mineral Content Comparison

Mineral Icelandic Glacial (mg/L) Mananalu (mg/L) Calcium 5.7 N/A Magnesium 2.2 N/A Sodium 11 N/A

Mineral content and pH levels are key factors in evaluating the health and hydration benefits of these bottled waters.

Environmental Impact

Both Icelandic Glacial and Mananalu place a strong emphasis on minimizing their environmental impact. Key areas to consider include sustainability practices, carbon footprint considerations, and waste reduction strategies.

Sustainability Practices

Icelandic Glacial takes pride in sourcing water from Iceland's Ölfus Spring, a renewable resource. Their facilities are designed with green technology, optimizing energy use to lower environmental impact.

Mananalu focuses on eliminating single-use plastics by packaging water in 100% recyclable aluminum cans. Founder Jason Momoa emphasizes the importance of using materials that are easier to recycle and have a longer lifecycle compared to traditional plastic bottles.

Both companies demonstrate a commitment to sustainable practices through their choices of materials and facility operations.

Carbon Footprint Considerations

Icelandic Glacial offsets its carbon emissions by using hydroelectric and geothermal energy sources. The company is recognized as a CarbonNeutral® product and operation, emphasizing their efforts in maintaining a low carbon footprint.

Mananalu aims to reduce carbon emissions by using lightweight aluminum cans, which are more energy efficient to transport due to their reduced weight. Additionally, the company supports reforestation projects as part of their carbon offset strategy.

Both companies actively work to minimize their carbon footprints through energy-efficient operations and carbon offset initiatives.

Waste Reduction Strategies

Icelandic Glacial integrates waste reduction into their production by utilizing recyclable PET plastic bottles. They have also implemented closed-loop recycling systems in their manufacturing processes.

Mananalu's decision to use aluminum cans addresses the issue of plastic waste directly. Aluminum is highly recyclable, with a significant percentage of aluminum being reused in new products.

These strategies highlight the companies' efforts to reduce waste and promote recycling, contributing to less environmental pollution.

Through these distinct approaches, both Icelandic Glacial and Mananalu strive to address the environmental challenges associated with bottled water production and consumption.

Water Source and Purity

Icelandic Glacial water claims origin from natural springs filtered through volcanic rock, while Mananalu sources purified water with a mission to reduce plastic waste.

Comparing Natural Sources

Icelandic Glacial Water comes from the Ölfus Spring, an ancient, naturally replenished spring in Iceland. The water is filtered through layers of volcanic rock, enriching it with minerals like calcium, magnesium, and potassium.

Mananalu, on the other hand, sources its water from purified municipal sources. While it does not claim a unique natural origin, it emphasizes its environmental commitment by using 100% recyclable aluminum cans. The choice between natural spring water and municipal sources can influence both taste and mineral content.

Purity and Contaminant Levels

Icelandic Glacial Water prides itself on its purity, tested to ensure low levels of contaminants. The volcanic rock filtration process naturally reduces impurities, maintaining water quality that meets stringent standards set by environmental agencies like the EPA.

Mananalu undergoes rigorous purification processes to remove contaminants from municipal water sources. Despite lacking a natural origin, the water is thoroughly tested to meet EPA standards. Mananalu's purification ensures it is free from harmful contaminants, focusing on providing clean and safe drinking water in an environmentally friendly package.

Packaging and Convenience

Packaging plays a significant role in the overall experience of using bottled water. Icelandic Glacial and Mananalu have distinct packaging choices with environmental considerations and consumer convenience at the forefront.

Effects of Packaging on Quality

Icelandic Glacial water is packaged in BPA-free plastic and recyclable glass bottles. The materials used are designed to preserve the natural purity and taste of the water. Glass bottles offer a premium feel and are environmentally friendlier, but they are heavier and more prone to breaking, impacting transportation efficiency.

Mananalu prioritizes sustainability with 100% recyclable aluminum cans. Aluminum is light and durable, reducing the risk of breakage. It's an effective barrier against light and air, helping to maintain water quality for a longer time. Brita Premium Purified Water takes a similar approach by using aluminum containers.

Convenience for Consumers

Icelandic Glacial's packaging options, including glass and plastic, cater to different consumer preferences. Glass bottles are aesthetically pleasing and often preferred for their premium feel. The availability in grocery stores and online adds to the convenience. However, the weight and fragility of glass can be a drawback for on-the-go use.

Mananalu’s aluminum cans are lighter and more portable, making them a practical choice for transportation and everyday use. They fit easily in refrigerators and are available in multi-packs, suitable for bulk purchasing. The compact size and durability of aluminum make it convenient for various scenarios, from daily hydration to outdoor activities.

Taste Profile

The taste profile of Icelandic Glacial and Mananalu bottled water varies significantly, influenced by the mineral content and the expertise of water sommeliers. Understanding these differences is crucial to discerning which brand might best suit your palate.

Mineral Content and Water Taste

Mineral content directly impacts the taste of bottled water. Icelandic Glacial, sourced from an ancient lava field in Iceland, boasts a naturally alkaline composition. This includes elements like magnesium and silica, which impart subtle mineral notes that enhance its clean and crisp taste.

Mananalu, meanwhile, focuses on sustainability and packaging. Although less detailed in mineral composition specifics than Icelandic Glacial, Mananalu still provides a refreshing and balanced taste, without strong mineral aftertastes. Its water undergoes meticulous filtration processes to ensure purity and a pleasant drinking experience.

The Role of a Water Sommelier

Water sommeliers specialize in identifying the nuanced flavors of different bottled waters. They examine factors like mineral content, pH level, and source.

A water sommelier might note that Icelandic Glacial's unique volcanic filtration process yields a smooth but distinctively crisp taste. Its slight mineral presence can be more enjoyable when consumed chilled. Conversely, Mananalu's filtration results in a more universally appealing taste profile, marked by its refreshing and pure attributes.

By appreciating these expert insights, consumers can better understand the subtle differences that make each type of bottled water unique.

Health Considerations

Choosing between Icelandic Glacial and Mananalu involves careful evaluation of their pH, electrolyte content, and total dissolved solids (TDS). These components are crucial for understanding the health implications of each water brand.

Evaluating pH and Electrolyte Content

Icelandic Glacial boasts a high alkaline level with a pH of 8.4, making it a good option for those looking for alkaline water that is known to potentially neutralize acid in the body. Its mineral profile is balanced, with low concentrations of key electrolytes such as calcium and magnesium.

Mananalu water, on the other hand, also aims for purity but does not highlight a specific pH level. Instead, it emphasizes its sustainability and the purity achieved by its purification processes. Although less detailed about electrolyte content, it generally offers purified water that may have variable electrolyte levels.

Key Components:

  • Icelandic Glacial:

    • pH: 8.4

    • Calcium: 5.7 mg/L

    • Magnesium: 2.2 mg/L

    • Sodium: 11 mg/L

  • Mananalu:

    • pH: Not specified

    • Electrolytes: Variable

This information helps in determining which brand better meets specific health needs, such as those requiring higher pH levels or balanced electrolytes.

Understanding Total Dissolved Solids (TDS)

Total dissolved solids (TDS) are a measure of all organic and inorganic substances in water. Icelandic Glacial has relatively low TDS, signifying its purity. This can be beneficial for individuals who need low-mineral water for particular health reasons or prefer the taste of less mineralized water.

Mananalu emphasizes its clean and purified water, but TDS levels are not prominently stated. Its focus is more on environmental impact and the use of 100% recyclable aluminum cans, rather than specific mineral content.

Comparative Table of TDS:

Brand TDS Level Icelandic Glacial Low (exact value unspecified) Mananalu Not specified (varies)

This comparison indicates that while Icelandic Glacial offers detailed information about mineral content and TDS, Mananalu prioritizes sustainability and environmental considerations.

Consumer Information

When choosing between Icelandic Glacial and Mananalu, consumers often consider factors like quality reports, certifications, and the specific types of water these brands offer. Understanding these details helps make an informed decision.

Quality Reports and Certifications

Icelandic Glacial sources its water from Iceland's Ölfus Spring, one of the world’s largest natural springs. This water is naturally filtered through volcanic rock, ensuring a high standard of purity. The company holds certifications such as CarbonNeutral® product and operations certifications, demonstrating its commitment to quality and environmental responsibility.

Mananalu, launched by Jason Momoa, emphasizes sustainability. The water, sourced from natural springs in the U.S., undergoes rigorous purification processes. Mananalu's commitment to eliminating single-use plastics is underscored by its packaging in 100% recyclable aluminum cans. The brand’s quality reports and certifications reflect its dedication to both product purity and environmental goals.

Water Brands and Consumer Choices

Icelandic Glacial:

  • Type: Natural spring water

  • Source: Ölfus Spring, Iceland

  • Packaging: Plastic bottles

  • Attributes: High purity, mineral-rich

Mananalu:

  • Type: Purified water

  • Source: Various U.S. springs

  • Packaging: Aluminum cans

  • Attributes: Environmentally friendly, sustainable packaging

Consumers prioritizing natural mineral content may lean towards Icelandic Glacial, known for its pristine spring source. Those focused on sustainability and reducing plastic waste might prefer Mananalu, with its eco-friendly aluminum packaging. Both brands provide detailed information on their sourcing and purification processes, enabling a well-rounded understanding for buyers.

Market Comparison

The bottled water market features a variety of brands with differing price points and quality. This segment highlights Icelandic Glacial and Mananalu, focusing on their pricing, quality, and availability.

Price Versus Quality

Icelandic Glacial prides itself on providing pure, refreshing water sourced from Iceland. It positions itself as a premium product with a corresponding price tag. This contrasts with brands like Aquafina and Dasani, which are more budget-friendly but often criticized for taste.

Mananalu, endorsed by Jason Momoa, also targets the premium segment. Packaged in aluminum to reduce single-use plastics, it is typically priced higher than standard bottled waters such as Arrowhead. Consumers often associate higher costs with better environmental impact and a unique brand appeal.

Market Presence and Availability

Icelandic Glacial enjoys a strong market presence globally and is often found in high-end stores and online platforms. According to customer reviews, it has built a loyal customer base, particularly noted for its clean taste and packaging.

Mananalu, though newer, aims to disrupt the market with its sustainable focus. It is not as widely available as Icelandic Glacial but can be found in specialty stores and online.

The comparison between Icelandic Glacial and Mananalu highlights differences in market strategy and consumer reach, each catering to a specific segment within the premium bottled water market.

Final Verdict

Both Icelandic Glacial and Mananalu offer unique benefits focusing on purity and environmental consciousness. This section breaks down their key differences.

Summarization of Key Differences

Environmental Impact: Mananalu, founded by Jason Momoa, prioritizes environmental sustainability by packaging water in 100% recyclable aluminum cans and partnering with rePurpose Global to remove plastic waste. Icelandic Glacial, known for utilizing eco-friendly practices, uses BPA-free bottles made from recycled materials and emphasizes a low carbon footprint in their production processes.

Source and Purity: Icelandic Glacial sources its water from the Ölfus Spring in Iceland, known for its natural filtration through volcanic rock. This results in water with a balanced mineral content. Mananalu's water is purified via advanced filtration techniques, ensuring a clean taste but without the specific mineral content offered by Icelandic Glacial.

Market Presence: Mananalu is widely available online and in stores like Safeway, Whole Foods, and Sprouts Market. Icelandic Glacial is distributed globally and found in major retailers, supporting a strong international presence.

Bottom Line: Mananalu is the choice for environmentally-conscious consumers aiming to reduce plastic waste. Icelandic Glacial appeals to those prioritizing natural purity and rich mineral content.

More About Icelandic Glacial

More About Mananalu

Muhammad Shahid
Previous

Icelandic Glacial vs. Open Water
Next

Icelandic Glacial vs. Liquid Death