Hawai’i Volcanic vs. Mananalu

Written By Muhammad Shahid

Which Bottled Water is Better?

In the world of bottled water, Hawai’i Volcanic and Mananalu are making waves with their unique offerings and strong environmental missions. For those looking for a sustainable option, Mananalu's 100% recyclable aluminum cans stand out as a significant advantage over single-use plastic bottles. This aligns with the company's mission to eliminate plastic waste, a vision championed by its founder, Jason Momoa.

On the other hand, Hawai’i Volcanic water prides itself on being naturally sourced from the pristine volcanic springs of Hawaii, offering a taste that many purists describe as clean and refreshingly pure. Their commitment to maintaining the natural integrity of their water adds a layer of authenticity and appeal for those seeking a pure drinking experience.

Both brands offer compelling benefits, but the choice between Hawai’i Volcanic's natural purity and Mananalu's strong environmental commitment ultimately depends on individual priorities. Readers will find that each has carved out a distinct niche in the bottled water market, promising quality hydration with a deeper purpose.

Overview of Hawai’i Volcanic and Mananalu

Both Hawai’i Volcanic and Mananalu are premium bottled water brands with strong commitments to the environment and sustainability. These brands are known for unique sourcing methods and effective market strategies to attract eco-conscious consumers.

Brand Origins: Hawai’i Volcanic and Mananalu

Hawai’i Volcanic sources its water from a deep well at the Mauna Loa volcano in Hawai’i. The water is naturally alkaline, filtered through volcanic rock, resulting in a smooth, slightly sweet taste. It prides itself on preserving the natural balance of minerals and electrolytes in the water.

Mananalu, founded by actor Jason Momoa, known for his role in Aquaman, aims to tackle plastic pollution. The name combines "Mana," meaning sacred spirit, and "Nalu," meaning wave. This brand offers purified water in recyclable aluminum bottles, pushing against single-use plastics.

Environmental Vision and Mission

Hawai’i Volcanic commits to sustainability by sourcing its water in an environmentally friendly manner. The brand emphasizes the natural filtration of volcanic rock and uses sustainable methods to ensure minimal environmental impact.

Mananalu places a strong emphasis on eliminating single-use plastic bottles. Partnering with rePurpose Global, the brand removes plastic waste from the ocean. The use of aluminum bottles, which are infinitely recyclable, aligns with its mission to protect the environment.

Market Presence and Availability

Hawai’i Volcanic water is marketed as a premium product available at upscale retailers like Whole Foods Market. Its unique flavor profile and natural sourcing appeal to health-conscious consumers in the United States.

Mananalu has gained attention largely due to Jason Momoa's Hollywood influence. This brand is available online through platforms like Amazon and in select stores. Its eco-friendly packaging and celebrity backing make it a popular choice for those looking to make environmentally conscious decisions.

Product Composition and Sources

Hawai’i Volcanic and Mananalu offer distinct features in their product composition and sourcing methods. Their unique approaches cater to different consumer preferences, making it important to analyze their ingredients and sources closely.

Ingredients Profile Comparison

Hawai’i Volcanic is known for its alkaline water composition, with a pH level of about 9, which is above neutral. The water contains natural minerals like silica, magnesium, potassium, and calcium, sourced from volcanic rocks. These minerals are believed to provide various health benefits.

Mananalu, on the other hand, provides triple-filtered purified drinking water with added electrolytes and a neutral pH of approximately 7. The water aims to offer purity and hydration, primarily focusing on eliminating single-use plastics by packaging in 100% aluminum cans.

Sourcing and Extraction

Hawai’i Volcanic sources its water from deep Hawaiian aquifers, which are replenished by rain and filtered through volcanic rock formations. This natural filtration process adds beneficial minerals and maintains the water's purity.

Mananalu sources its water within the United States, ensuring minimal carbon footprint during transportation. The water is responsibly extracted and processed to guarantee sustainability. They use BPA-free aluminum cans, promoting environmental responsibility.

Both brands prioritize sustainability; Hawai’i Volcanic by leveraging natural volcanic filtration and Mananalu by providing a substantial alternative to single-use plastic bottles.

Environmental Impact and Sustainability

Hawai’i Volcanic and Mananalu are committed to reducing their environmental footprint through innovative packaging, strategic partnerships, and carbon offset initiatives. Their approaches differ in the types of materials they use and the specific programs they support.

Packaging Materials and Recyclability

Mananalu uses 100% recyclable aluminum bottles. Aluminum is noted for being infinitely recyclable, meaning it can be reprocessed without degradation in quality. This choice helps to combat the plastic pollution problem plaguing oceans and landfills.

Hawai’i Volcanic, on the other hand, often utilizes RPET (Recycled Polyethylene Terephthalate), which is made from recycled plastic bottles. While not infinitely recyclable, RPET has a lower carbon footprint compared to virgin plastic.

Initiatives and Partnerships

Mananalu has partnered with various organizations to amplify its environmental impact. An example is their collaboration with Hawaiian Airlines to replace plastic water bottles with aluminum ones in premium cabins. They also have initiatives like "Drink One, Remove One," which aims to eliminate a piece of plastic for every bottle sold, often through partnerships with conservation organizations such as Repurpose Global.

Hawai’i Volcanic is affiliated with 1% for the Planet, donating 1% of sales towards environmental causes. They also collaborate with conservation-focused organizations aiming to protect natural water resources and reduce pollution. Their efforts often focus on holistic environmental care rather than just packaging.

Carbon Footprint and Offsets

Mananalu works to minimize its carbon footprint through efficient supply chain management and carbon offsets. They aim to ensure that their aluminum bottles, supplied by companies like Ball Corp, are sourced and recycled in an eco-friendly manner. Their operational strategies are specifically designed to reduce climate change impact.

Hawai’i Volcanic focuses on renewable energy within their supply chain to lessen their carbon footprint. They employ local sourcing methods to minimize transportation emissions and invest in carbon offset programs. They aim to be carbon neutral by supporting projects that reduce climate change impacts and improve environmental health.

Both companies display strong commitments to sustainability but take different paths in their packaging, partnerships, and carbon strategies.

Product Offerings and Features

Both Hawai’i Volcanic and Mananalu offer products with unique benefits tailored to environmentally conscious consumers. They stand out by focusing on packaging and design, and they also provide ancillary products and services that extend beyond just bottled water.

Varieties and Flavors

Hawai’i Volcanic provides a range of still and sparkling water options. Their sparkling water comes in several flavors including lemon, lime, and pineapple, targeting consumers who prefer a flavored hydration experience.

Mananalu focuses solely on purified drinking water. Their product is enriched with electrolytes and maintains a neutral pH of approximately 7, ensuring it is both hydrating and balanced. While they do not offer flavored varieties like Hawai’i Volcanic, their emphasis is on purity and health benefits.

Packaging and Design

Mananalu uses 100% recyclable aluminum cans, which are BPA-free and resealable. The durability and sustainability of aluminum make it a popular choice for environmentally conscious consumers. Their packaging is also designed to be sleek and convenient for on-the-go hydration.

Hawai’i Volcanic offers their products in both glass bottles and recyclable plastic containers. They emphasize the premium aesthetic with elegantly designed bottles that reflect their commitment to quality and luxury. Their packaging aims to combine practicality with a touch of sophistication, appealing to a broader market.

Ancillary Products and Services

Mananalu provides additional services such as free shipping for bulk orders, making it easier for customers to access their products. They have partnered with organizations and events, offering their water in various settings to promote sustainability.

Hawai’i Volcanic offers a range of Pono-branded merchandise, promoting their ethos of living “pono” or righteously. They also engage heavily in community support, advocating for Hawaiian culture and environmental causes. This includes educational programs and participation in environmental clean-up activities.

Their emphasis on ancillary products and services highlights their commitment to not only providing beverages but also promoting a sustainable and culturally respectful lifestyle.

Consumer Experience and Social Initiatives

Exploring the consumer experience and social initiatives provides insight into what sets Hawai’i Volcanic and Mananalu apart. Both brands have unique founding stories and initiatives that resonate with consumers committed to environmental sustainability.

Brand Awareness and Cultural Impact

Hawai’i Volcanic leverages its deep-rooted connection to the Hawaiian Islands to build brand awareness. The company emphasizes its origins in Hawaii, promoting the purity of volcanic-filtered water. This connection appeals to environmentally conscious consumers and those drawn to the brand's cultural authenticity.

Mananalu, founded by Jason Momoa, utilizes his celebrity status to boost visibility. Momoa’s identity as a Hawaiian native and the ethos of the brand resonate with a global audience. His influence has positioned Mananalu not only as a water brand but also as a platform for environmental activism.

Community Support and Projects

Hawai’i Volcanic is active in supporting local Hawaiian communities. The brand participates in various initiatives to protect natural resources, partnering with local organizations to ensure sustainable water sourcing. Their community-focused projects often include educational programs to raise awareness about environmental conservation.

Mananalu’s "Drink One, Remove One" campaign aims to remove single-use plastics from the ocean. This initiative aligns with broader global movements, including collaboration with the United Nations. Mananalu's efforts expand to communities beyond Hawaii, with programs extending support to regions like Africa. The brand’s projects often feature videos and media content to garner wider support for its mission.

Comparison and Conclusion

Hawai’i Volcanic and Mananalu approach the bottled water industry with unique missions and attributes.

Mananalu offers purified water in 100% recyclable aluminum cans. Founded by Jason Momoa, this brand prioritizes reducing single-use plastics and landfills.

Hawai’i Volcanic highlights its water sourced from Hawaii’s volcanic rocks, rich in minerals. The brand positions itself as sustainable and eco-conscious.

Attribute Hawai’i Volcanic Mananalu Cost Mid-range Moderate Refillable No No Reusable No Yes (aluminum cans) Single-Use Plastics Avoided by both Avoided by both Industry Leader Emerging Recognized

Environmental Impact:

The use of aluminum cans by Mananalu combats plastic water bottle usage. Hawai’i Volcanic emphasizes sustainable practices but uses plastic bottles which may contribute to environmental waste.

Cultural and Ethical Considerations:

Hawai’i Volcanic aligns with Hawaiian culture and respects the land, including issues surrounding the Thirty Meter Telescope on Mauna Kea.

Consumer Preference:

Mananalu’s focus on renewable packaging might attract environmentally conscious buyers. Hawai’i Volcanic’s mineral-rich profile appeals to those looking for naturally sourced hydration.

Both brands bring strong qualities to the market. Their different approaches in packaging and sourcing highlight varying contributions to sustainability and consumer choice.

More About Hawai’i Volcanic

More About Mananalu

Muhammad Shahid
Previous

Hawai’i Volcanic vs. Open Water
Next

Hawai’i Volcanic vs. Liquid Death