Just Water vs. Hawai’i Volcanic: Which Bottled Water is Better?

A Comparative Analysis of Premium Bottled Waters

Choosing the right bottled water can be a subtle but significant choice for those who value taste, purity, and health benefits. Just Water and Hawai’i Volcanic Water stand out among other brands, each offering unique qualities that cater to different needs and preferences. Just Water, known for its sustainability practices and clean taste, boasts packaging made from primarily renewable resources.

Hawai’i Volcanic Water, sourced from the Mauna Loa volcano, offers naturally alkaline water and is filtered through porous lava rock, providing a unique mineral profile. For those seeking a sustainable choice, Just Water might be the better option due to its environmental focus, whereas health enthusiasts might prefer Hawai’i Volcanic for its natural mineral content and alkaline properties.

These distinct attributes make both brands equally appealing, but the best choice largely depends on individual preferences and priorities.

Background on Bottled Water

Bottled water has become a prevalent choice for hydration, often perceived as purer and more convenient compared to tap water. The industry has evolved significantly over the years, driven by varying consumer preferences and health considerations. This section delves into the historical development and factors that propelled bottled water into a staple of modern life.

Evolution of Bottled Water

The history of bottled water goes back to Roman times when it was stored in glass containers. More recently, bottled water gained popularity in the late 20th century. Originally marketed for its mineral content and perceived purity, innovations in packaging and distribution further propelled its growth.

In the United States, the industry witnessed a surge in the 1970s, attributed to awareness around healthy hydration and a demand for convenient, on-the-go drinking water. By the late 1990s, the variety of water types such as spring water, mineral water, and enhanced water with added electrolytes or pH adjustments became available.

Modern bottled water brands now emphasize source purity, including options like Hawai'i Volcanic, which market unique mineral compositions and health benefits. This differentiation among brands is driven by the competitive landscape and stringent consumer expectations for quality and safety.

Overview of JUST Water

JUST Water prides itself on offering not only a hydrating experience but also a commitment to sustainability. This section delves into the origins and environmental impact of JUST Water.

Origin and Source

JUST Water originates from Upstate New York, where it is sourced from a naturally renewable spring. The water is part of a unique system that collects rainwater, which then seeps through layers of soil and rock.

The company emphasizes the importance of sustainable extraction. By tapping into an aquifer, they ensure that the water source is continually replenished by the natural water cycle. This approach helps maintain the environment's balance and preserves the water source for future generations.

JUST Water is often praised for its pure and refreshing taste, which many attribute to the natural filtration process. This process preserves essential minerals, adding to the water's overall health benefits.

Environmental Impact

JUST Water stands out for its eco-friendly packaging and commitment to sustainability. The brand uses bottles made from 82% renewable resources, primarily paper cartons derived from responsibly managed forests. Additionally, the caps are made from sugarcane, a more sustainable alternative to conventional plastic.

The entire bottle is 100% recyclable, encouraging consumers to minimize waste. JUST Water's use of RPET (Recycled Polyethylene Terephthalate) for the bottle lining further reduces its carbon footprint. These materials are lighter than traditional plastic, which reduces transportation emissions.

JUST Water’s sustainable practices extend to their partnership with communities to ensure fair use of local resources. This holistic approach to environmental stewardship aligns with their mission to provide pure water without compromising the planet's health.

Overview of Hawai'i Volcanic Water

Hawai'i Volcanic Water, sourced from the Mauna Loa volcano, is renowned for its natural filtration, impressive mineral content, and sustainable practices. This section explores its distinctive natural filtration process, the health benefits it offers, and its commitment to sustainability.

Natural Filtration Process

Hawai'i Volcanic Water begins its journey as snowmelt and rain on the slopes of the Mauna Loa volcano, the world's largest shield volcano. The water then percolates through thousands of feet of porous volcanic rock. This natural filtration process not only purifies the water but also enriches it with essential minerals. The volcanic rock acts as a natural filter, providing a unique composition that includes minerals like calcium, potassium, magnesium, silica, and sodium. This inherent geological feature makes Hawai'i Volcanic Water naturally alkaline, with a pH range of 7.6 to 8.2.

Health Benefits

Hawai'i Volcanic Water offers various health benefits due to its rich mineral content. The presence of minerals such as calcium and silica contributes to bone and joint health, while magnesium supports muscle function. Potassium helps maintain electrolyte balance, and sodium is essential for hydration. The naturally alkaline pH of Hawai'i Volcanic Water can aid in neutralizing acid in the body, potentially offering a more balanced internal environment. This mineral-rich profile and the water's alkaline nature make it a favorable choice for those seeking both hydration and nutritional benefits.

Sustainability Efforts

Sustainability is a core component of Hawai'i Volcanic Water’s philosophy. Situated at the eastern base of Mauna Loa, Waiākea, one of the brands associated with Hawai'i Volcanic Water, prioritizes eco-friendly practices. The company employs sustainable sourcing methods, drawing water from a deep well that is naturally replenished. Additionally, the brand is committed to reducing its carbon footprint and has implemented various initiatives to achieve this goal. Through the Kokua Initiative, Waiākea focuses on community support and environmental preservation, ensuring a symbiotic relationship with the stunning ecosystem of the Big Island. The use of recycled materials for packaging further showcases its dedication to sustainability.

Comparative Analysis

Just Water and Hawai’i Volcanic are two bottled water brands with distinct characteristics. This section explores several key features to help determine which might be the better choice for consumers.

Nutrient Profile

Just Water is notable for its inclusion of essential minerals, which contribute to its slightly alkaline pH. The brand emphasizes sustainable sourcing, ensuring that the water maintains its natural mineral content.

In contrast, Hawai’i Volcanic is known for its unique volcanic filtration process, which also enriches the water with minerals such as magnesium and calcium. Both brands offer beneficial nutrients, but the specific mineral content varies due to differing sources and filtration methods.

pH Levels and Alkalinity

Just Water maintains a pH level of 8.0, which places it in the slightly alkaline category. This alkalinity is achieved through its natural mineral content, promoting a balanced pH that is beneficial for hydration and bodily functions.

Hawai’i Volcanic takes it a step further with a pH level of 8.5, making it more alkaline. This higher alkalinity, derived from the volcanic rock filtration, is said to provide additional health benefits, including improved acid-base balance.

Environmental Considerations

One of Just Water’s standout features is its packaging. The water is contained in a carton made predominantly of paper, with a plant-based plastic cap. This innovative approach significantly reduces plastic waste, aligning with the brand’s sustainability mission.

Hawai’i Volcanic also emphasizes environmental sustainability. The brand uses recycled plastic for its bottles, aiming to mitigate the environmental impact associated with traditional plastic containers. Both brands prioritize sustainability but employ different methods to achieve their eco-friendly goals.

Taste and Palate

The taste of Just Water is often described as crisp and clean, thanks to its balanced mineral composition. The use of natural spring sources ensures a refreshing experience without any off-putting aftertastes.

Hawai’i Volcanic, sourced from Hawaiian volcanic springs, offers a distinct and slightly more robust flavor profile. Consumers often report a smoother and more mineral-rich taste, attributed to its volcanic origins. The unique filtration process imparts a subtle but noticeable difference, enhancing the overall drinking experience.

Health and Hydration

When comparing Just Water and Hawai’i Volcanic in terms of health and hydration, it's essential to look at their mineral content, acidity levels, and overall benefits to the body. Each brand provides unique health advantages linked to its distinct sources and processing methods.

Hydration and Mineral Benefits

Hydration is vital for maintaining bodily functions, and both Just Water and Hawai’i Volcanic claim to excel in this area. Just Water is marketed for its purity and minimal processing. It retains naturally occurring minerals like calcium and magnesium, which are crucial for bone health and muscle function.

Hawai’i Volcanic offers a naturally alkaline pH level of 8.8, higher than many regular bottled waters. This alkalinity could help neutralize acidity in the body, promoting better digestion and enhanced hydration, especially for athletes. The mineral content in Hawai’i Volcanic includes sodium, potassium, and silica. These elements aid in muscle recovery, maintain electrolyte balance, and support collagen production.

Supporting a Healthy Life

Both brands contribute to a healthy lifestyle through their distinct mineral compositions. Just Water is sourced with a focus on sustainability and safety, ensuring it remains a good choice for everyday consumption. It is known for its balanced minerals, supporting immune function and hydration without added chemicals or flavors.

Hawai’i Volcanic’s higher pH level and mineral-rich profile make it suitable for those looking to support their digestive health and immune system. The presence of electrolytes like sodium and potassium is beneficial for maintaining blood pressure and nerve function. The silica content supports joint and bone health, making Hawai’i Volcanic an excellent choice for active individuals seeking holistic support for their health.

Impact on Environment and Society

The environmental and societal impacts of Just Water and Hawai’i Volcanic focus on their bottling processes and corporate responsibility. These aspects are crucial, given the increasing concerns about sustainability.

Bottling Processes

Just Water uses plant-based plastic bottles known as rPET (recycled polyethylene terephthalate), which reduce traditional plastic use and contribute to a lower carbon footprint. Their packaging is designed to be recyclable and environmentally friendly. The use of plant-based materials aims at reducing reliance on fossil fuels and minimalizing landfill waste.

Hawai’i Volcanic, however, opts for aluminum bottles. Aluminum is highly recyclable and retains its quality even after repeated recycling processes. This choice aligns with efforts to minimize environmental impact, though aluminum production is energy-intensive. Moreover, the transport of materials to and from the volcanic islands might involve greater energy consumption compared to Just Water's local sourcing.

Corporate Responsibility

Just Water is committed to sustainability and ethical practices. They support various community projects and emphasize the importance of using renewable resources. Their business model promotes transparency and responsibility, tackling environmental issues head-on, from the production line to the end consumer.

Hawai’i Volcanic places a strong emphasis on preserving the natural beauty of Hawaii. They champion environmental conservation and support local communities through charitable initiatives. Their corporate efforts aim to protect water resources and reduce plastic pollution in the oceans, reflecting a commitment to social and environmental stewardship.

Both companies demonstrate a significant focus on reducing environmental impact and fostering social responsibility, albeit through different approaches and materials.

Consumer Considerations

When comparing Just Water and Hawai’i Volcanic, it's crucial to look at various factors such as cost, convenience, accessibility, and brand ethics to help consumers make an informed choice.

Cost Comparison

Cost is a significant factor in choosing bottled water. Just Water often positions itself as a premium option, but it manages to keep prices relatively competitive through the use of plant-based packaging.

Hawai’i Volcanic, known for its volcanic origin, generally comes with a higher price tag. This premium pricing is attributed to its unique sourcing and proprietary filtration processes.

Consumers on a budget might lean toward Just Water, while those willing to spend more for unique sourcing might opt for Hawai’i Volcanic.

Convenience and Accessibility

Just Water has a strong retail presence. Its environmentally friendly packaging often catches the eye in grocery stores and online platforms.

Hawai’i Volcanic, on the other hand, is often found in specialty health stores and high-end markets. Its availability might be limited in comparison, making it less convenient for the average consumer.

For easier and broader accessibility, Just Water stands out, especially for those who seek convenience in everyday purchases.

Brand Ethics and Values

Both brands prioritize sustainability and environmental consciousness, but they do so in different ways. Just Water emphasizes its use of plant-based cartons and its focus on renewable resources.

Hawai’i Volcanic promotes the natural purity of its water source and commits to protecting its volcanic ecosystem. It also engages in various charitable activities and environmental support programs.

Consumers deeply concerned with ethical considerations might appreciate the strong environmental and social commitments from both brands, but Just Water's innovative packaging may appeal to those particularly interested in reducing plastic waste.

Final Thoughts

When it comes to choosing between Just Water and Hawai’i Volcanic, key considerations revolve around aspects such as the origin, hydration benefits, taste, environmental impact, health benefits, sustainability, cost, and convenience.

Choosing the Right Water for You

Origin:
Just Water is sourced from Glen Falls, New York, while Hawai’i Volcanic is drawn from volcanic springs in Hawaii. The source can influence the mineral content and purity of the water.

Hydration:
Both options provide excellent hydration. Just Water boasts a balanced pH, while Hawai’i Volcanic offers naturally occurring electrolytes, which support quicker hydration.

Taste:
Taste preferences may vary. Just Water has a clean and neutral flavor, whereas Hawai’i Volcanic has a slightly mineral-rich taste, influenced by its volcanic origin.

Environment:
Just Water highlights its eco-friendly packaging made of 82% renewable resources, including a bio-plastic cap. Hawai’i Volcanic also focuses on sustainability, emphasizing minimal environmental footprint through its entire production process.

Health Benefits:
Hawai’i Volcanic’s high alkaline pH can help neutralize body acidity, promoting overall wellness. Just Water also provides essential minerals but in a balanced pH, making it suitable for daily consumption.

Sustainability:
Both brands prioritize sustainability. Just Water uses renewable materials, while Hawai’i Volcanic maintains very low water harvest rates to minimize environmental impact.

Cost:
Price competitiveness is essential for consumers. Just Water often offers affordability with broader availability, whereas Hawai’i Volcanic may come at a premium due to its exotic source.

Convenience:
Both brands offer convenient packaging, with Just Water’s carton design being easily portable and stackable. Hawai’i Volcanic’s bottles are also user-friendly and practical for various settings.

Just Water vs. Hawai’i Volcanic

A Comparative Analysis of Premium Bottled Waters