Simple Truth vs. Open Water

Written By Muhammad Shahid

Bottled Water Comparison

Choosing a bottled water often comes down to quality, taste, and environmental impact. For eco-conscious consumers, the debate between Simple Truth and Open Water is quite relevant. Simple Truth offers a range of natural, purified drinking waters often marketed as a healthier and cleaner option. Alternatively, Open Water distinguishes itself with its eco-friendly aluminum bottles, promising a reduced environmental footprint.

When comparing these two brands, Open Water stands out for its commitment to sustainability, offering aluminum packaging that is infinitely recyclable. Meanwhile, Simple Truth focuses on purity and health, providing various options that cater to different dietary needs and preferences. Both brands offer a clean, refreshing taste, but the materials they use for packaging could influence your choice.

Consumers looking for an eco-friendly option may lean towards Open Water, while those prioritizing a variety of natural water choices might prefer Simple Truth. This article delves deeper into the taste, quality, and environmental factors to help you make an informed decision about your bottled water preference.

Background and Origin of the Brands

Simple Truth and Open Water are two popular bottled water brands, each with unique origins and brand philosophies. This section will examine the history and background of these brands to understand their market positioning better.

Simple Truth Brand Analysis

Simple Truth is a private label brand owned by The Kroger Co., one of the largest supermarket chains in the United States. The brand was introduced to offer natural and organic products, including bottled water.

The Simple Truth bottled water is sourced from Crystal Falls Springs in Michigan. It is marketed as artesian water with an emphasis on being a natural and alkaline option. The brand aims to provide affordable yet high-quality products accessible to the average consumer, emphasizing natural purity and minimal environmental impact.

Open Water Brand Analysis

Open Water was founded with a strong focus on sustainability and environmental responsibility. The founders recognized the need for more eco-friendly alternatives to plastic bottled water. Based in Chicago, Illinois, Open Water offers water packaged in recyclable aluminum bottles and cans.

The water is sourced from underground aquifers in the US and is purified using reverse osmosis. Open Water brands itself around combating plastic pollution and promoting recycling, aiming to make a significant positive impact on the environment. The company strongly advocates reducing single-use plastics and encourages customers to recycle its packaging.

Water Sourcing and Types

Simple Truth and Open Water bottled waters have distinct sources and characteristics, each offering unique benefits such as mineral content or natural purity.

Source of Simple Truth Water

Simple Truth is a brand under Kroger, sourcing its water from natural springs. These springs typically provide spring water, which bubbles up naturally to the surface or can be extracted through boreholes.

Spring water is valued for maintaining natural minerals, contributing to its taste and health benefits. Simple Truth’s spring water is likely to have a balanced mineral content, enhancing hydration and overall wellness. The spring water sourced by Simple Truth ensures minimal processing, preserving the water's natural state and quality.

This sourcing method ensures that the water meets regulatory standards for spring water, offering a clean and refreshing alternative to other water types.

Source of Open Water

Open Water sources its water differently, focusing on sustainability and environmental impact. The water often comes from artesian wells, where water is trapped underground between layers of rock and pushed upward naturally.

Artesian water is known for being pure and often has a higher mineral content, making it similar to mountain valley water in quality. This sourcing method requires drilling to access the underground reservoir, ensuring naturally filtered water.

Some Open Water products may also use alkaline water, which has higher pH levels to balance acidity in the body. This adds a unique aspect to Open Water, offering a different hydration experience compared to the neutral pH of natural spring water.

These sourcing practices enable Open Water to provide a product that is both healthy and environmentally responsible.

Water Quality and Purification Methods

In examining the water quality and purification methods of Simple Truth and Open Water, it’s essential to look at their distinct purification techniques and filtration processes. Comparing these methods reveals how each brand ensures the safety and clarity of their products.

Simple Truth Purification

Simple Truth bottled water undergoes a multi-step purification process. Initially, the water is sourced from municipal supplies, which already adhere to strict regulatory standards. It then goes through a reverse osmosis system. This method forces water through a semi-permeable membrane, effectively removing contaminants such as lead and heavy metals.

After reverse osmosis, Simple Truth incorporates ozonation. Ozonation uses ozone gas to disinfect the water, eliminating any remaining bacteria and viruses. This ensures microbial safety without the use of chemical disinfectants.

Simple Truth also monitors the pH level of the final product, aiming to maintain a balanced pH that is neither too acidic nor too alkaline. This attention to pH balance helps in preserving the taste and quality of the water.

Open Water Filtration Technique

Open Water takes a different route with its filtration technique. Like Simple Truth, their water starts from a municipal source, ensuring compliance with safety standards. The water then undergoes a series of filtration steps, beginning with activated carbon filters to remove organic contaminants and chlorine.

Following carbon filtration, Open Water applies an advanced reverse osmosis process. This method is crucial for removing impurities such as heavy metals and other dissolved solids. Reverse osmosis in Open Water’s case ensures purity by providing a high level of filtration efficiency.

The final step in Open Water's process includes UV light treatment and ozonation. These steps serve to kill any potential bacteria or viruses, ensuring a clean and safe product. The inclusion of ozonation adds an extra layer of security by addressing microbial contamination without the need for chemical additives.

Health and Hydration Benefits

The health and hydration benefits of bottled water can be influenced by the water's electrolyte balance and its mineral content. Understanding these factors can help consumers make informed choices between Simple Truth and Open Water.

Hydration and Electrolyte Balance

Proper hydration is crucial for bodily functions, and electrolytes play a key role in maintaining fluid balance. Simple Truth and Open Water both aim to provide effective hydration, but they differ in their electrolyte content.

Simple Truth often includes natural electrolytes like sodium, potassium, and bicarbonate. These electrolytes help the body retain water and maintain nerve and muscle function.

Open Water, known for its sustainability focus, is usually purified through reverse osmosis. This process removes most minerals, so additional electrolytes might be added to improve hydration.

Electrolytes such as sodium and potassium help to balance pH levels and replenish lost minerals after physical activity. Checking labels for these elements can help consumers choose the best option for their hydration needs.

Mineral Content and Health Enhancements

Mineral content in water can contribute to various health benefits. Minerals like calcium and magnesium found in some bottled waters support bone health and metabolic functions.

Simple Truth tends to include natural minerals, enriching the water with calcium and magnesium. These minerals not only contribute to hydration but also have potential health benefits such as improving bone density and aiding muscle function.

Open Water may include added minerals to enhance taste and provide health benefits. Calcium supports cardiovascular health, while magnesium is essential for energy production and muscle relaxation.

Consumers looking for water that supports daily mineral intake might prefer products with higher natural or added mineral content. Comparing labels for these minerals will aid in selecting the water that aligns best with personal health goals.

Taste Profile and Mouthfeel

Simple Truth and Open Water each provide a unique sensory experience for consumers, distinguishing them in the premium bottled water market. Examining their taste profiles and mouthfeel reveals notable differences.

Analyzing Simple Truth's Taste

Simple Truth water is appreciated for its neutral taste. This makes it an ideal choice for individuals who prefer minimal mineral interference in their hydration experience. The taste can be described as clean and unobtrusive, allowing for easy consumption without any lingering aftertaste.

In terms of mouthfeel, Simple Truth offers a crisp and refreshing sensation. The water's texture is smooth, with no noticeable hardness or metallic flavors. This makes it suitable for daily drinking and can be a favorite among those who appreciate straightforward hydration.

Understanding Open Water’s Flavor

Open Water is known for its distinct clean taste. Unlike some competitors, Open Water focuses on purity and low mineral content, creating a crisp, clear flavor. It's designed to appeal to those who are conscious of both taste and environmental impact, given its sustainable packaging approach.

The mouthfeel of Open Water is characterized by a subtle velvety texture. This tactile quality provides a luxurious sensation, often noted by water sommeliers. The presence of a smooth finish enhances its drinkability, making it a preferred choice among water enthusiasts seeking both taste and texture in their beverages.

Packaging and Environmental Impact

Both Simple Truth and Open Water have implemented unique packaging strategies aimed at reducing environmental impact and promoting sustainability.

Simple Truth Packaging Initiatives

Simple Truth uses a blend of 74% paper, 1% aluminum, and 25% plastic film for their packaging. This combination reduces the overall use of plastic compared to traditional plastic bottles but still includes some plastic components.

In communities where carton recycling is available, their packaging can be more environmentally friendly. Customers are encouraged to recycle the boxes properly to minimize waste.

They also prioritize BPA-free materials to reduce the risk of chemical leaching associated with plastics. By using a predominantly paper-based design, Simple Truth aims to position itself as an eco-friendly alternative to conventional bottled water options.

Open Water's Eco-Friendly Approach

Open Water focuses on using aluminum cans and glass bottles, both of which are highly recyclable materials. Aluminum cans are known for their infinite recyclability, meaning they can be recycled repeatedly without losing quality.

This approach significantly reduces plastic waste and aligns with eco-friendly practices. The company's emphasis on reusability extends to their glass bottles, which can be reused multiple times before recycling.

By choosing materials that are readily recyclable, Open Water targets a reduction in their overall environmental footprint. They also emphasize the lower carbon emissions associated with aluminum and glass compared to plastic, making their packaging a sustainable choice for environmentally conscious consumers.

Cost Analysis and Consumer Value

When considering bottled water, both affordability and pricing play crucial roles in determining consumer value. This section breaks down the cost-related aspects of Simple Truth and Open Water, focusing on their potential impact on an individual's budget.

Affordability of Simple Truth

Simple Truth offers a budget-friendly option in the bottled water market. Priced competitively, it aims to cater to consumers looking for inexpensive yet quality water. Bulk purchasing options enhance its value, making it a practical choice for those with limited resources.

Monthly expenses for regular consumers remain low, helping manage a household budget effectively. Additionally, the brand's commitment to eco-friendly packaging may appeal to value-conscious individuals prioritizing sustainability.

Example:

  • Single Bottle (500ml): $0.99

  • Pack of 24 (500ml each): $20.99

Pricing of Open Water

Open Water positions itself as a premium brand, resulting in higher individual costs. The use of aluminum bottles, which are more sustainable than plastic, adds to its expensiveness. Despite the higher price, some consumers find value in its environmental benefits and personal health assurance.

The upfront cost may deter budget-conscious buyers, but for those willing to spend more for quality and sustainability, Open Water offers a compelling option.

Example:

  • Single Bottle (500ml): $2.29

  • Pack of 24 (500ml each): $49.99

These details underscore the divergent paths Simple Truth and Open Water take in balancing cost with consumer value, highlighting their respective strengths in affordability and premium pricing.

Regulatory Compliance and Safety

Ensuring safe drinking water and adherence to federal regulations are key priorities for both Simple Truth and Open Water. This section examines how each brand meets safety standards and legal limits set by regulatory bodies such as the FDA.

Simple Truth's Safety Standards

Simple Truth follows stringent guidelines to ensure the safety and quality of its bottled water. The brand adheres to FDA regulations, which are as rigorous as those set by the EPA for tap water. Additionally, Simple Truth implements good manufacturing practices to maintain high standards during processing and bottling.

Legal limits for contaminants in bottled water are strictly observed. Routine testing is conducted to verify compliance. Simple Truth ensures its water is safe for consumption by regularly inspecting and sampling its products. This guarantees the bottled water consistently meets necessary safety protocols.

Convenience and Availability

Simple Truth and Open Water differ significantly in their distribution channels and market reach. These factors directly impact their convenience and availability to consumers across the United States.

Simple Truth's Distribution Channels

Simple Truth is Kroger's private-label brand, making it widely available in Kroger's extensive network of supermarkets and affiliated stores. This network includes numerous regions across the United States.

Additionally, Simple Truth bottled water can often be spotted on the shelves of other grocery chains under Kroger's ownership.

Shoppers can also purchase Simple Truth products online through Kroger's website. This gives customers the option to have bottled water delivered to their homes or ready for pickup.

Open Water's Market Reach

Open Water prioritizes sustainability, and their aluminum bottled waters can be found in many eco-conscious retailers. Their focus on sustainability extends to partnerships with niche stores, co-ops, and health food markets.

Open Water's market reach might be narrower compared to larger brands.

However, their presence is expanding through online platforms. Customers can buy Open Water products through e-commerce sites which significantly increases their accessibility. Open Water also aims to be convenient for travelers, making their products available at select airports and hotels.

Consumer Opinions and Brand Reputation

Evaluating consumer perceptions of Simple Truth and Open Water offers insight into the strengths and weaknesses of each brand. A close look at feedback and brand reputation contributes to understanding public preferences.

Public Perception of Simple Truth

Consumers appreciate Simple Truth for its reliable taste and trusted sourcing. This brand, part of the Kroger family, enjoys a reputation for consistency and availability.

Many users commend Simple Truth’s clean and refreshing taste. The packaging often highlights the natural spring sources, adding to its appeal.

Instances of negative feedback are generally rare, with occasional mentions of minor taste inconsistencies. Overall, its reputation benefits from Kroger's wide distribution and established trust.

Open Water's Customer Feedback

Open Water focuses on sustainability, using recyclable aluminum bottles. This commitment to environmental responsibility resonates with eco-conscious consumers.

Feedback frequently touches on the brand’s smooth taste and the convenience of its sustainable packaging. While some users mention higher prices, they often justify it with the environmental benefits.

The brand's reputation for innovation and quality is frequently highlighted in customer reviews and reports. The preference for Open Water is often tied to its broader mission of reducing plastic waste.

The Bottom Line: Which Water Wins?

When deciding between Simple Truth and Open Water, several factors come into play.

Packaging: Open Water stands out with its eco-friendly aluminum cans that are 100% recyclable. Simple Truth typically uses plastic bottles, which may not be as sustainable.

Taste: Simple Truth provides a clean, crisp taste, while Open Water is known for its refreshing purity. The choice often boils down to personal preference.

Price: Open Water generally costs more due to its environmentally friendly packaging. Simple Truth offers a more budget-friendly option without sacrificing quality.

Health and Safety: Both brands meet strict safety standards. Yet, the focus on plastic alternatives in Open Water’s packaging may appeal to those concerned about potential health risks from microplastics.

Comparison Table

Factor Simple Truth Open Water Packaging Plastic bottles Aluminum cans Taste Clean and crisp Pure and refreshing Price More affordable Generally more expensive Health and Safety Meets safety standards Minimizes microplastic risk

Recommendation

For eco-conscious consumers, Open Water may be the better choice due to its sustainable packaging. However, for those seeking a cost-effective option with a clean taste, Simple Truth is a strong contender.

Each path has its advantages, making the final decision a matter of personal priorities and values.

More About Simple Truth

More About Open Water

Muhammad Shahid
Previous

Simple Truth vs. Ophora
Next

Simple Truth vs. Kirkland Signature