Open Water vs. 1907water

Written By Muhammad Shahid

A Clear Comparison of Bottled Waters

Choosing the right bottled water can be a task in itself, especially with so many options on the market. Among the plethora of choices, Open Water and 1907water stand out for their unique qualities and benefits. Both brands offer something distinct, but which one truly deserves a spot in your refrigerator?

When comparing Open Water to 1907water, 1907water comes out ahead due to its naturally alkaline pH and source from New Zealand's pristine springs. Open Water, known for its eco-friendly aluminum packaging, also has its merits, particularly for those prioritizing sustainability in their consumer choices.

For those who value both the purity and sustainability of their bottled water, understanding the key differences and benefits of Open Water and 1907water is essential. This article will delve into the specifics of each brand, ensuring you make an informed choice next time you're in the bottled water aisle.

Examining the Sources

The origins and environmental impacts of bottled waters are crucial to consider when determining which product is better. Open Water and 1907water both have unique attributes worth examining to assess their overall quality and sustainability.

Water Source Comparisons

Open Water is sourced from a deep aquifer in the United States. This aquifer provides clean, fresh-tasting water that is purified through advanced filtration processes.

1907water comes from artesian water sources in New Zealand, known for its ancient, pristine spring water.

Mineral Profile: Open Water often highlights its purity with minimal mineral content, appealing to those who prefer a clean taste. In contrast, 1907water emphasizes its natural mineral content, which contributes to a slightly sweet flavor, enhancing the drinking experience.

Taste: Open Water's filtration process aims to create a consistent, neutral flavor. Meanwhile, the mineral-rich composition of 1907water offers a distinct, velvety texture and taste that some consumers find more appealing.

Environmental Footprints of Water Sources

Packaging: Open Water prides itself on using recyclable aluminum bottles, which have a significantly lower environmental impact compared to single-use plastic. The Environmental Working Group supports minimizing plastic use due to its environmental repercussions.

Carbon Footprint: 1907water's transport from New Zealand to various global markets raises concerns about carbon emissions. Although the source is sustainable, the transportation process adds to its environmental footprint.

Sustainability Practices: Open Water focuses on local sourcing and sustainability, aiming to reduce overall environmental impact. In contrast, despite 1907water’s pristine source, the long-distance shipping may negate some of its eco-friendly benefits.

Examining these factors can guide consumers in making an informed choice between the two brands based on both quality and environmental considerations.

Health and Safety Analysis

Consumers prioritize health and safety when choosing bottled water. This section takes a close look at contaminants, purity, and the mineral content of Open Water and 1907water, informing readers about what they are drinking.

Evaluating Contaminants and Purity

The purity of bottled water is essential for safe drinking. According to studies, some brands contain various contaminants, including plastic-derived chemicals, solvents, and fertilizers.

Open Water and 1907water both adhere to strict testing protocols. Open Water undergoes multiple filtration processes to remove impurities. 1907water sources its water from an artesian aquifer, ensuring a naturally filtered product.

Regulation standards by the FDA and EPA apply to both brands. Continuous testing is conducted to ensure compliance with the Safe Drinking Water Act, maintaining high safety and quality standards.

Comparing Mineral Contents

Mineral content is another vital aspect of bottled water. Open Water and 1907water differ in their natural mineral compositions, affecting taste and health benefits.

Open Water is known for being ultra-purified, containing minimal mineral content. This may appeal to those looking for pure, clean-tasting water.

1907water boasts balanced levels of essential minerals like calcium and magnesium due to its natural source. This can contribute positively to overall health by providing minerals that support bodily functions.

A comparison table of mineral content:

Mineral Open Water (mg/L) 1907water (mg/L) Calcium 2 10 Magnesium 1 8

These differences can guide consumers in selecting water that meets their nutritional needs.

Taste and Quality Assessment

In comparing Open Water and 1907water, two key factors stand out: their taste and overall water quality. Breaking down how each performs in blind taste tests and examining their chemical composition and pH levels will provide clarity on which bottled water is superior for different consumer preferences.

Blind Taste Tests Findings

Open Water and 1907water underwent several blind taste tests to gauge their flavor profile without brand biases. Participants ranked the waters based on taste, mouthfeel, and aftertaste.

Open Water:

  • Crisp, clean taste

  • Slight mineral undertone

1907water:

  • Smooth, soft taste

  • Mild sweetness

Many testers mentioned an affinity for 1907water's softness, while Open Water often received praise for its refreshing and straightforward flavor. The cohort's feedback suggested that while both brands deliver high-quality taste, individual preferences might sway depending on whether one prefers smoothness or crispness.

Chemical and pH Considerations

The chemical makeup and pH levels are crucial in determining the health benefits and suitability of bottled water for different needs.

Open Water:

  • pH level: around 7.4 (slightly alkaline)

  • No added minerals

  • Naturally purified

1907water:

  • pH level: around 8.2 (alkaline)

  • Contains electrolytes and minerals like calcium and magnesium

The pH levels indicate that 1907water is more alkaline, which can be beneficial for those seeking to balance their body's pH. Open Water's more neutral pH makes it a versatile choice. Differences in their mineral content can also impact the overall health benefits and taste, with 1907water offering an added boost from its electrolytes.

Packaging and Sustainability

The environmental impact of bottled water is a critical factor for many consumers. This section compares the packaging and sustainability efforts of Open Water and 1907water, focusing on bottle design, materials, and their environmental implications.

Bottle Design and Materials

Open Water uses aluminum bottles, which are highly recyclable and designed for multiple uses. Aluminum's durability makes it a preferred choice over single-use plastic. These bottles also feature resealable caps, enhancing convenience for users looking to reuse or recycle.

1907water opts for PET plastic bottles, which are lighter and more flexible than aluminum. While PET is recyclable, its usage must be carefully managed to avoid environmental drawbacks. The materials for these bottles primarily include PET, known for its wide recyclability but limited reuse potential.

Environmental Implications of Bottling

Aluminum bottles from Open Water significantly reduce the reliance on single-use plastic. Aluminum recycling processes can be highly efficient, lessening the need for new materials. These bottles' reusability also ensures fewer items end up in landfills, aligning with Environmental Protection Agency guidelines.

On the other hand, 1907water's PET plastic bottles, while recyclable, often face challenges in the recycling chain. Improper disposal can contribute to increased landfill usage and environmental degradation. Despite being lighter, reducing transportation emissions, PET's short lifespan compared to aluminum impacts its overall environmental friendliness.

In summary, Open Water’s focus on aluminum provides a sturdy, reusable option, whereas 1907water offers a lighter but potentially less sustainable PET alternative.

Cost and Accessibility

Examining the cost and accessibility of Open Water and 1907water provides important insights for consumers evaluating these two bottled water options.

Pricing and Value Considerations

Open Water tends to position itself as a premium brand. Consumers can expect to pay around $1.50 to $2.00 per bottle, depending on the retailer. The higher price point often reflects the brand’s commitment to using aluminum packaging, which is more expensive but also more environmentally friendly.

1907water typically offers a competitive pricing model. A standard bottle often sells for $1.00 to $1.50. Despite being less expensive, 1907water sources its water from New Zealand, a factor that may contribute to perceived value due to its purity claims.

In the table below, key pricing points are summarized:

| Brand | Price per Bottle | |------|-------------------| | Open Water | $1.50 - $2.00 | | 1907water | $1.00 - $1.50 |

Ultimately, whether the higher cost of Open Water offers better value can depend on a consumer's priorities, including environmental concerns.

Water Availability and Choices

Open Water is generally available at major retailers and online stores. Its emphasis on sustainable packaging makes it popular in eco-conscious markets, but it may be less available in smaller or rural outlets.

1907water is broadly distributed, with availability in convenience stores, supermarkets, and health-focused retail chains. Its sourcing from New Zealand provides a unique selling point, appealing to consumers who prioritize quality and origin.

Both brands offer various bottle sizes and packaging options. Open Water’s aluminum bottles come in multiple sizes, while 1907water features recyclable plastic bottles and larger multi-bottle packs.

In terms of choice, both brands offer adequate options, but availability might depend widely on geographic location and retailer partnerships.

Regulatory and Industry Standards

Bottled water is regulated at multiple levels to ensure safety and quality. This section explores the key aspects of government regulations and industry compliance.

Government Regulations and Oversight

Bottled water is subject to rigorous government regulations to ensure safety and quality. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is the primary federal authority for bottled water, regulating it under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act. These regulations encompass testing for contaminants and setting allowable limits for substances like lead and bacteria.

In contrast, tap water is regulated under the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA) by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The EPA mandates water quality reports, which public water systems must provide annually to consumers. Both regulatory frameworks aim to guarantee safe drinking water, but they differ in specific requirements and oversight.

Industry Compliance and Certifications

In addition to federal and state regulations, the bottled water industry often adheres to standards set by trade associations. The International Bottled Water Association (IBWA) is a key player, promoting industry best practices through its Bottled Water Code of Practice. This includes standards for water source protection, production, and packaging.

Many bottled water brands seek additional certifications to enhance consumer trust. For example, NSF International provides independent certification for bottled water, ensuring it meets stringent safety and quality standards. Adherence to these certifications demonstrates a commitment to exceeding mandatory regulatory requirements, providing consumers with an added layer of assurance about the quality and safety of their drinking water.

Consumer Preferences and Behavior

Consumer choices in bottled water are influenced by various factors, including perceived quality, convenience, and brand trust. Both Open Water and 1907Water have their own dedicated consumer bases, with different market trends and public perceptions shaping their popularity.

Market Trends in Bottled Water Consumption

The popularity of bottled water continues to rise, driven largely by its convenience and the growing awareness of hydration's importance.

Many consumers have shifted from sugary beverages to bottled water, considering it a healthier choice. In surveys, a significant percentage of Americans express a preference for bottled water over tap water, citing reasons like taste and perceived purity.

Interestingly, brands like Open Water, which markets itself on sustainability by using aluminum packaging, appeal to environmentally-conscious consumers.

1907Water, sourced from New Zealand's pure aquifers, resonates with those who prioritize natural and high-quality hydration.

Data indicates a growing trend towards premium and ethically-sourced bottled water, suggesting that consumers are willing to pay more for brands they trust.

Public Perception and Trust

Public trust in bottled water brands plays a crucial role in consumer behavior. Surveys indicate that many Americans believe bottled water is safer and of higher quality than tap water.

While Open Water's commitment to reducing plastic waste builds trust among eco-friendly consumers, 1907Water's emphasis on purity and natural sourcing appeals to health-conscious buyers.

Brand loyalty is often cultivated through consistent quality and effective marketing.

For instance, Open Water highlights its environmental impact reduction, endorsing its mission to provide a sustainable alternative.

1907Water leverages its exotic origin and rigorous purification processes to assure consumers of its superior quality.

Both brands successfully foster trust and loyalty by emphasizing unique selling points that align with consumer values.

Comparative Brand Review

Open Water and 1907water are two distinct bottled water brands that emphasize purity and sustainability. This section will focus on their unique characteristics, origins, and packaging to help readers make an informed choice.

Open Water Profile

Open Water is a leading brand in environmentally friendly bottled water. Packaged in aluminum cans, Open Water aims to reduce plastic waste significantly. The brand’s dedication to sustainability is a major selling point, especially for eco-conscious consumers.

Origins: Open Water sources its water from fresh, clean municipal sources. They ensure stringent filtration and purification processes to offer high-quality drinking water.

Packaging: Aluminum cans are 100% recyclable, which contrasts with traditional plastic bottles. This choice minimizes the carbon footprint and promotes a circular economy. Open Water’s packaging is robust and keeps the water cold longer than plastic alternatives.

Taste: The water is marketed as crisp and clean, free from the plastic taste that can sometimes affect other bottled waters. This makes it comparable to reputable brands like Essentia in terms of quality and flavor.

1907water Profile

1907water is a premium bottled water brand originating from New Zealand. Known for its natural purity, 1907water offers a distinctive taste profile and a commitment to quality.

Origins: Sourced from an ancient artesian aquifer in New Zealand, 1907water boasts a naturally alkaline pH level. This unique source contributes to its smooth, clean taste, which sets it apart from other bottled water brands.

Packaging: The brand uses BPA-free plastic bottles that are fully recyclable. Though not as environmentally friendly as Open Water’s aluminum cans, 1907water still emphasizes the importance of sustainable practice.

Taste: This water is celebrated for its smoothness and balanced mineral content. The naturally alkaline nature makes it a favorite for those seeking health benefits associated with alkaline water. The profile competes well against other premium options like Fiji.

Both brands highlight different strengths, catering to a range of consumer preferences.

More About Open Water

More About 1907water

Muhammad Shahid
Previous

Open Water vs. 7-Select
Next

Nestlé Pure Life vs. Zenwtr