Poland Spring vs. 1907water

Written By Muhammad Shahid

Which Bottled Water is Better for You?

Poland Spring and 1907water are two renowned bottled water brands that consumers often debate over. While Poland Spring offers a heritage tied to natural springs in Maine, 1907water brings the purity of New Zealand's artesian waters to the forefront. Both brands emphasize quality and health, making them popular choices for hydration.

Poland Spring, sourced from various springs in Maine, boasts a crisp taste that many find refreshing. On the other hand, 1907water, with its unique artesian origin, provides a distinct smoothness that appeals to those with a discerning palate. The taste variations between these two brands can significantly influence consumer preference, particularly for individuals seeking either a familiar or exotic experience.

In terms of health benefits, both Poland Spring and 1907water maintain their reputations. Poland Spring ensures low sodium content, catering to those mindful of their sodium intake, while 1907water's natural mineral composition offers a pleasant balance for overall wellness. This direct comparison highlights the unique strengths of each brand, providing readers with crucial insights for making an informed choice.

Overview of Bottled Water Industry

The bottled water industry has witnessed significant growth over the past few decades. Consumers are drawn to the convenience and perceived purity of bottled water. Major players like Nestlé Waters, Aquafina, Dasani, and Evian dominate the market.

Sales of bottled water have outpaced other beverages, reflecting increasing health consciousness among consumers. Marketing strategies play a pivotal role in this growth, emphasizing purity, safety, and convenience.

Major Brands

  • Nestlé Waters: Offers a diverse range of bottled water brands, including Poland Spring.

  • Aquafina: Known for its rigorous purification process.

  • Dasani: Focuses on a refreshing taste with added minerals.

  • Evian: Marketed as natural mineral water from the French Alps.

The bottled water market is highly competitive, with brands vying for consumer loyalty through distinctive taste profiles and innovative packaging. Environmental concerns have led to a growing interest in sustainable packaging solutions and recycling programs.

Brand History and Origins

Poland Spring and 1907water originate from distinct and unique regions, with each brand reflecting the environmental and natural resources of their respective locations. This section will cover their historical roots and development over time.

Poland Spring Roots

Poland Spring's origins trace back to 1845 in the small town of Poland, Maine. The brand began when Hiram W. Ricker discovered the natural spring on his family's farmland. Recognizing the potential, he started bottling the water and selling it commercially.

In 1859, the brand was officially born, and Poland Spring became known for its pure and natural spring water. Over time, it grew into one of the most recognized bottled water brands in the United States.

The brand's success can be attributed to the natural resource it draws from—pristine springs in Maine. These springs are noted for their clean, refreshing taste. Today, Poland Spring operates as a subsidiary of BlueTriton Brands, formerly known as Nestlé Waters North America.

1907water New Zealand Genesis

1907water originates from the Waiwera Artesian Aquifer in New Zealand. The brand was founded in 2008, capitalizing on the pure and untouched waters of this aquifer. This source is situated in a region known for its natural beauty and environmental purity.

The aquifer itself dates back thousands of years, with water that is naturally filtered through subterranean rock layers. This process imparts a unique mineral composition and a crisp taste to 1907water.

New Zealand's strict environmental regulations ensure the sustainable management of 1907water's resources. This commitment to environmental impact and quality sets the brand apart. By marketing itself as a premium water brand, 1907water has carved out a niche in the global bottled water market.

Water Source and Quality

Poland Spring and 1907water take pride in their distinctive sources and unique compositions. Poland Spring focuses on the purity of its natural spring water, while 1907water emphasizes its unique artesian aquifer origins.

Poland Spring's Natural Spring Water

Poland Spring sources its water from various springs in Maine, most notably in the foothills of the Appalachian Mountains. This natural spring water is renowned for its clean and crisp taste, flowing naturally to the surface from underground springs.

The water is filtered through layers of sand and gravel, which ensures its purity and enriches it with natural minerals. Poland Spring adheres to stringent EPA and FDA safety standards to ensure the water remains free of contaminants and heavy metals. The brand’s water is noted for its consistent quality, with a balanced electrolyte and mineral content that contributes to its refreshing taste.

1907water's Artesian Aquifer

1907water is sourced from an artesian aquifer located in New Zealand. This groundwater is naturally filtered through layers of volcanic rock, which imparts a unique mineral composition and an alkaline pH level of 7.8.

The water has a clean and smooth taste, high in natural electrolytes and minerals, making it a preferred choice for those seeking naturally balanced water. 1907water prides itself on maintaining high purity standards, consistently testing its water to ensure it meets FDA regulations and remains free from contaminants and dissolved solids. This dedication to quality ensures a distinctive taste that sets it apart from other brands.

Taste and Mineral Content

The taste and mineral content of bottled water play a crucial role in determining its preference among consumers. Poland Spring and 1907water differ in these aspects, each providing unique characteristics and benefits.

Characterizing Poland Spring's Profile

Poland Spring Water is sourced from multiple springs in Maine. It has a taste profile that is described as refreshing with a smooth finish. This is due to its balanced mineral content, which includes calcium, magnesium, and electrolytes.

The magnesium content in Poland Spring water aids in muscle function and overall health. Calcium, another key mineral, benefits bone health. The pH levels of Poland Spring range from neutral to slightly alkaline, contributing to its clean, crisp taste without a strong aftertaste.

1907water Taste & Benefits

1907water is sourced from a remote spring in New Zealand and is known for its soft, refreshing taste. The low mineral content, particularly in terms of calcium and magnesium, gives it a delicate flavor that is less noticeable compared to other bottled waters.

The water contains essential electrolytes that assist in hydration and overall well-being. Its pH level is slightly alkaline, which some consumers find beneficial for maintaining a balanced body pH. The clean finish with minimal aftertaste makes it a favored choice for those who prefer a subtler taste profile.

Processing and Purity

Poland Spring and 1907water each have unique methods for ensuring the purity and quality of their bottled water, from rigorous purification processes to natural filtration methods.

Poland Spring Purification Standards

Poland Spring is known for following stringent purification protocols to maintain the high quality of its 100% Natural Spring Water. They utilize multiple stages including Reverse Osmosis and Ultraviolet Light treatments to ensure that any impurities are effectively removed.

The brand boasts that its water complies with FDA Regulations, and uses third-party testing to validate the purity and quality of their bottled water. Ozone treatment is another method employed that aids in sterilizing the water without altering its natural taste. Each source is rigorously tested to meet both FDA and stricter internal guidelines.

1907water Natural Purity and Filtration

1907water prides itself on the natural purity of its water, which originates from deep aquifers in New Zealand. The natural spring water is filtered naturally through ancient volcanic rocks, providing a high degree of inherent purity without the need for extensive artificial treatments.

The water undergoes minimal processing and avoids the use of Reverse Osmosis or Ozone treatment, relying instead on the natural filtration properties of its source. This process preserves the natural minerals and the unique taste profile of 1907water. Its purity is supported by regular quality checks that ensure it meets and often exceeds international water standards.

Health and Hydration

When comparing Poland Spring to 1907water in terms of health and hydration, several factors come into play. Both brands aim to provide high-quality bottled water, but they differ in mineral content and pH levels.

Poland Spring draws its water from multiple spring sources in Maine. It is marketed as 100% natural spring water. This type of water often contains essential minerals such as calcium and magnesium, contributing to daily mineral intake.

1907water, sourced from New Zealand, is known for its high pH level, often around 8.0. Alkaline water advocates argue that this can help neutralize stomach acid and improve hydration. The elevated pH also makes it different from typical bottled water options.

Electrolyte content is another crucial aspect. Poland Spring's mineral mix provides natural electrolytes that aid in maintaining fluid balance and muscle function.

1907water emphasizes the purity of its source and the naturally occurring electrolytes, contributing to efficient hydration without artificial additives.

Here’s a brief comparison:

Poland Spring 1907water Source Multiple Springs, Maine New Zealand pH Level Approximately 7.0 Approximately 8.0 Minerals Calcium, Magnesium Calcium, Magnesium Electrolytes Natural Electrolytes Natural Electrolytes

Both brands offer benefits tailored to different hydration preferences. Choosing the right one depends on individual health priorities and taste preferences.

Environmental and Ethical Considerations

Poland Spring and 1907water both face scrutiny regarding their environmental impact and ethical practices. Key aspects include their packaging and recycling practices, as well as their water sourcing methods.

Packaging and Recycling Practices

Poland Spring, owned by BlueTriton, has faced criticism over the environmental effects of its plastic bottles. Reports indicate that the bottles may contain harmful microplastics and phthalates, raising public health and environmental concerns.

1907water highlights its use of BPA-free bottles, aiming to reduce the adverse impacts of plastic waste. The brand also focuses on promoting recycling, with clearer labeling on bottles to facilitate proper disposal.

Both brands are under pressure to enhance their packaging methods, with customers increasingly demanding sustainable and eco-friendly solutions. Their efforts play a crucial role in the broader conversation about plastic waste and recycling.

Sustainable Water Sourcing

Poland Spring has been criticized for sourcing practices that some argue are not transparent. Allegations suggest that the company may sell water that is no different from ordinary groundwater. This has led to legal disputes and public backlash.

1907water sources its water from the aquifers of New Zealand, emphasizing the purity and sustainability of its methods. The company stresses its commitment to environmentally responsible extraction practices, ensuring minimal impact on local ecosystems.

Consumer awareness about the importance of ethical water sourcing continues to grow, putting pressure on both Poland Spring and 1907water to maintain high standards in their extraction and bottling processes.

Market Presence and Consumer Trust

Poland Spring and 1907water both enjoy significant market presence but appeal to different consumer bases. This section will explore how each brand builds consumer loyalty and trust, as well as any controversies or lawsuits that have affected their reputation.

Consumer Loyalty and Brand Trust

Poland Spring, under the Nestlé umbrella, has established itself as a household name in the bottled water market. It leverages extensive marketing campaigns and a long history of sourcing water from natural springs to build consumer trust. Consumers often associate Poland Spring with reliability and quality, contributing to high brand loyalty.

1907water, although newer, positions itself as a premium brand focusing on natural artesian purity. Marketed at a higher price point, it attracts health-conscious consumers willing to pay more for perceived quality. The brand uses imagery of pristine sources to create a sense of exclusivity, which helps in building a loyal customer base.

Lawsuits and Controversies

Poland Spring has faced significant controversies, including a class-action lawsuit alleging that the brand’s water contains harmful microplastics. Tests by Consumer Reports found high levels of phthalates in Poland Spring water, raising concerns about safety and affecting consumer trust. Losing or settling such cases can have a lasting impact on the brand's market position.

1907water, by contrast, has not faced major legal challenges or controversies. Its emphasis on artesian purity and lack of significant legal issues contribute to a clean reputation. This can positively influence consumers who prioritize safety and environmental considerations in their purchasing decisions.

Final Assessment and Recommendations

Poland Spring and 1907water are both strong contenders in the bottled water market.

Quality: Poland Spring sources its water from various springs in Maine, ensuring a consistent and natural product. 1907water, originating from New Zealand, promises purity with its naturally alkaline properties. Each brand maintains rigorous standards to ensure high quality.

Taste: Poland Spring has a clean, crisp flavor favored by many. The taste is more neutral, making it a versatile choice. 1907water offers a distinct, smooth taste attributed to its unique mineral composition and alkaline nature. Individual preference plays a significant role in which is considered better.

Health Benefits: 1907water is notable for its natural alkalinity, which some believe aids in better hydration and maintaining pH balance. Poland Spring provides essential minerals that are naturally occurring in its source water, which contributes to daily dietary needs.

Market Presence: Poland Spring is widely recognized in the United States, with a long history dating back to the 19th century. Its strong market presence ensures easy availability. 1907water, while newer to the market, is gaining popularity, especially among those seeking premium bottled water options.

Hydration: Both brands effectively meet hydration needs. Poland Spring offers a refreshing option for everyday consumption. 1907water, with its alkaline profile, may provide enhanced hydration, making it a preferred choice for those with specific hydration goals.

Recommendation:

  • Choose Poland Spring if you value a historic brand with a crisp taste and essential minerals.

  • Opt for 1907water if you prioritize alkaline water and unique taste.

Both choices deliver excellent hydration and health benefits, satisfying varying consumer preferences.

More About Poland Spring

More About 1907water

Muhammad Shahid
Previous

Poland Spring vs. 7-Select
Next

Perrier vs. Zenwtr