Mountain Valley Spring Water vs. 1907water

Written By Muhammad Shahid

Which Bottled Water Reigns Supreme?

Water enthusiasts often debate which bottled water brand reigns supreme. Two prominent contenders in this ongoing discussion are Mountain Valley Spring Water and 1907water. These brands are known for their commitment to quality and purity, offering distinct characteristics that set them apart from the competition.

Mountain Valley Spring Water, sourced from the springs of Arkansas, consistently earns top marks for its light, clean, and slightly sweet taste. Its velvety texture with a hint of minerals has made it a favorite among consumers and earned it numerous awards, including recognition from the Berkeley Springs International Water Tasting. This makes Mountain Valley Spring Water the best choice for those seeking a crisp and refreshing drink.

In contrast, 1907water hails from New Zealand and prides itself on its pristine source, free from industrial pollutants. Known for its softening alkaline properties, 1907water offers a balanced flavor profile that appeals to a different palate. While both brands provide health-conscious options, the choice between Mountain Valley Spring Water and 1907water ultimately comes down to personal preference in taste and texture.

Company Profiles

This segment covers the key historical elements and an overview of Mountain Valley Spring Water and 1907water, shedding light on their origins and distinct characteristics.

History of Mountain Valley Spring Water

Mountain Valley Spring Water originates from the Ouachita Mountains in Hot Springs, Arkansas. Established in 1871, it has a rich legacy known for its natural mineral composition and absence of contaminants.

The brand gained notable recognition when prominent figures like Elvis Presley and President Dwight D. Eisenhower favored it.

Their spring water is lauded for its light, clean taste, and velvety texture which subtly hints at its mineral-rich source.

Overview of 1907water

1907water is an emerging bottled water brand hailing from New Zealand. Known for its alkaline properties, it is sourced from a deep aquifer, providing a unique mineral profile.

The water is embraced for its purity and naturally high pH level, targeting health-conscious consumers.

New Zealand's pristine environment contributes significantly to 1907water's appeal, positioning it as a premium choice in the bottled water market.

Water Sources and Natural Properties

Mountain Valley Spring Water and 1907water each source their water from unique, natural environments that impart distinct characteristics and benefits. Understanding the differences in their water sources and natural filtration processes helps highlight what makes each brand unique.

Spring Water vs. Artesian Water

Mountain Valley Spring Water is sourced from a natural spring in the Ouachita Mountains of Arkansas. Natural spring water, such as Mountain Valley's, is renowned for its crisp, clean taste. It emerges naturally from the ground and requires minimal processing.

In contrast, 1907water is an artesian water from New Zealand, drawn from deep artesian aquifers. Water held in artesian aquifers is typically pressurized and accessed by drilling, rather than flowing to the surface on its own. This type of water is often prized for its purity, as deep aquifers are less susceptible to surface contaminants.

Granite-Based Aquifers and Volcanic Rock Filtration

Mountain Valley Spring Water benefits from filtration through granite-based aquifers. As water percolates through these granite formations, it collects beneficial minerals and is naturally filtered. This process contributes to its refreshing and slightly sweet flavor, as well as its array of minerals like calcium and magnesium.

1907water undergoes natural filtration through layers of volcanic rock. This unique filtration process imparts a distinct mineral profile, giving the water a clean and crisp taste. Volcanic rock acts as a natural filter, removing impurities while preserving beneficial minerals. This creates a balanced water that is not only refreshing but also rich in electrolytes.

Both waters are celebrated for their natural purity and well-balanced mineral content, but the specific processes of filtration and geological conditions set them apart.

Health and Mineral Content

Mountain Valley Spring Water and 1907water both offer unique profiles of essential minerals, each contributing to potential health benefits. This section will explore the specific minerals present in both waters and their impacts on health.

Essential Minerals in Bottled Water

The mineral content in bottled water can vary greatly depending on the source. Mountain Valley Spring Water is known for its rich mineral content including magnesium, calcium, and potassium.

  • Magnesium: Vital for muscle function and energy production.

  • Calcium: Important for bone health and nerve signaling.

  • Potassium: Supports cardiovascular health and muscle function.

1907water, sourced from New Zealand, is also rich in minerals. Like Mountain Valley, it contains magnesium and calcium, and often includes bicarbonate.

  • Bicarbonate: Helps maintain pH balance and can aid digestion.

  • Mineral Content Comparison: Both brands offer a refreshing choice but differ in their specific mineral balances, which can influence taste and health benefits.

Health Benefits of Magnesium and Calcium

Magnesium and calcium are two essential minerals found in both Mountain Valley Spring Water and 1907water. They play crucial roles in maintaining overall health.

  • Magnesium: Known to help regulate blood sugar levels and improve symptoms of diabetes. It also supports muscle and nerve function, dictating how well muscles contract and relax.

  • Calcium: Crucial for strong bones and teeth. It also aids in blood clotting, muscle contraction, and regulating heart rhythms.

Balanced intake of these minerals can contribute to better overall health, such as reducing the risk of rheumatism and improving metabolic functions. Both water brands provide a natural source of these minerals, making them beneficial for daily consumption.

Taste Profiles and Water Quality

Mountain Valley Spring Water and 1907water are renowned for their distinct taste profiles and superior water quality. Comparing these two brands involves evaluating their pH levels, alkalinity, and the influence of total dissolved solids (TDS) on taste.

PH Levels and Alkalinity

The pH level of a water source can greatly affect its taste and perceived quality. Mountain Valley Spring Water typically has a pH level around 8.2, rendering it slightly alkaline. This alkalinity contributes to a clean, crisp taste that some consumers describe as velvety.

1907water, sourced from New Zealand, boasts a naturally alkaline pH of 8.0. This water’s smooth taste with subtle mineral notes is appreciated by many. The slight alkalinity in both brands' waters can neutralize acidity in the digestive system, which some consumers find beneficial.

Influence of Total Dissolved Solids on Taste

Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) include minerals, salts, and other small substances dissolved in water. The TDS level influences the water's flavor profile and mouthfeel. Mountain Valley Spring Water has a moderate TDS level, contributing to its balanced and smooth taste with subtle mineral hints.

In contrast, 1907water has a lower TDS level, providing a clean and slightly sweet flavor. High TDS levels often result in a richer, more pronounced taste, while lower levels offer a more neutral and refreshing drinking experience. Both brands have won numerous awards, recognized for their excellent taste and high water quality.

Packaging and Sustainability

The packaging and sustainability efforts of Mountain Valley Spring Water and 1907water are crucial factors that impact their environmental footprint and appeal to eco-conscious consumers.

Bottle Materials and BPA Content

Mountain Valley Spring Water offers their products in glass bottles and recently introduced 100% recyclable aluminum bottles. These materials are chosen for their superior recycling capabilities and lack of BPA (Bisphenol A), ensuring that the water remains uncontaminated by chemicals.

1907water, on the other hand, uses PET plastic bottles. While PET is recyclable, it does raise concerns regarding BPA content. The company assures that their bottles are BPA-free, providing a safer drinking experience. The choice of primary plastic packaging, however, might be less favorable from a sustainability perspective compared to Mountain Valley's glass and aluminum options.

Environmental Impact and Brand Initiatives

Mountain Valley aggressively promotes sustainability through its choice of materials. The use of glass and aluminum aligns with eco-friendly practices as these materials are more widely and efficiently recycled than plastic. The company's focus on sustainability is further emphasized by their goal to provide portable water solutions that do not compromise the environment.

1907water is also active in the sustainability space, emphasizing their efforts to reduce plastic waste. Their PET bottles are fully recyclable and the brand participates in initiatives aimed at minimizing environmental impact. Nevertheless, plastic’s lower recyclability rates compared to glass and aluminum might pose a challenge in terms of achieving higher sustainability standards.

Market Presence and Consumer Choice

Mountain Valley Spring Water and 1907water are two prominent bottled water brands with distinct market presences. Their availability and consumer preferences reflect their unique attributes and regional popularity.

Availability and Popularity Across Regions

Mountain Valley Spring Water is well-established in the United States, particularly notable for its Arkansas source. The brand's extensive distribution network ensures that consumers across various states can easily access its products. It's commonly found in supermarkets, health food stores, and online platforms.

1907water, sourced from New Zealand, has a growing presence in international markets. It is available in select grocery stores and online, appealing to consumers interested in premium, naturally alkaline water. The brand's exotic origin and unique mineral profile contribute to its allure.

Consumer Preferences and Brand Loyalty

Consumers of Mountain Valley Spring Water appreciate its balanced mineral content, which includes calcium, magnesium, and potassium. Many loyal customers favor the brand for its clean, velvety taste and organic bottling process. It has built a strong following among health-conscious individuals.

1907water attracts consumers seeking naturally alkaline water with high silica content. Its smooth taste and health benefits draw loyal customers who prioritize quality and purity. The brand's New Zealand origin is a key selling point, adding a sense of exotic prestige that resonates with a niche market segment.

Comparative Analysis

When evaluating Mountain Valley Spring Water and 1907water, three critical aspects stand out: price, quality, and third-party recognition. These elements offer a well-rounded understanding of which bottled water may best suit different preferences.

Price Point Comparisons

Pricing can significantly impact a consumer’s choice. Mountain Valley Spring Water is often positioned within the premium sector. It commands a higher price point due to its long-standing brand presence and marketing efforts emphasizing purity and taste.

In contrast, 1907water aims for affordability while maintaining quality. This brand typically offers competitive prices, making it accessible for consumers seeking high-quality water without breaking the bank.

Quality Assessments

Mountain Valley Spring Water and 1907water tout their high quality, but they differ in certain specifics. Mountain Valley is sourced from protected springs in the Ouachita Mountains, known for its balanced mineral content and crisp taste.

1907water, sourced from deep aquifers in New Zealand, prides itself on low TDS (Total Dissolved Solids), which suggests a cleaner, more neutral taste. pH levels for Mountain Valley range around 7.3 to 7.8, while 1907water advertises a pH of 8.0, making it slightly more alkaline.

Third-Party Reviews and Awards

Mountain Valley Spring Water has garnered numerous awards and positive reviews from entities like Thrillist. It has been honored for its commitment to quality, with accolades highlighting its taste and purity.

1907water also receives favorable reviews, particularly for its taste and affordability. While it may not boast the same number of awards as Mountain Valley, 1907water consistently ranks well in taste tests and consumer feedback. Both brands are widely regarded, with each shining in their way.

Closing Thoughts

Mountain Valley Spring Water and 1907water are both popular choices in the bottled water market. Each offers unique attributes catering to different preferences and needs.

Mountain Valley Spring Water is a spring water sourced from Arkansas. It boasts a balanced pH, and essential minerals like calcium, magnesium, and potassium. Many appreciate its clean, velvety texture and historical legacy.

1907water is an artesian water from New Zealand. This type of water is known for its natural filtration through volcanic rock, resulting in a soft and smooth taste. It also contains beneficial minerals but in varying amounts compared to Mountain Valley.

Key Attributes Comparison:

Attribute Mountain Valley Spring Water 1907water Source Arkansas, USA New Zealand Type of Water Spring Artesian pH Level Balanced Slightly Alkaline Essential Minerals Calcium, Magnesium, Potassium Varies Texture Velvety, Clean Soft, Smooth

For those prioritizing a rich history and a high mineral content, Mountain Valley might be the preferred choice.

Consumers seeking a water with a unique source and smooth taste might lean towards 1907water. Each brand offers essential minerals that support overall hydration and health.

When choosing the right bottled water, consider personal preferences and specific health needs. Both Mountain Valley Spring Water and 1907water provide quality hydration options for discerning consumers.

More About Mountain Valley Spring Water

More About 1907water

Muhammad Shahid
Previous

Mountain Valley Spring Water vs. 7-Select
Next

Mananalu vs. Zenwtr