Refreshe vs. 1907water: Which Bottled Water Brand is Superior?

A Comparative Analysis of Bottled Water Quality

Choosing the right bottled water can be more complicated than it seems, but understanding the key differences and benefits of each can help consumers make a more informed decision. In this comparison, the spotlight is on Refreshe and 1907water, two distinct brands offering unique benefits.

Refreshe, distributed by Better Living Brands LLC, provides a straightforward hydration option. On the other hand, 1907water stands out with naturally alkaline water sourced from New Zealand, promoting natural hydration with a clean taste. Those looking to balance cost, quality, and health benefits may find this comparison between Refreshe and 1907water invaluable.

By evaluating their taste, quality, and packaging, readers can determine which brand best suits their needs. Whether you prioritize the natural sources and benefits of 1907water or the practical aspects of Refreshe, this article will guide you through making the best choice for your lifestyle.

Comparing Refreshe and 1907water

Refreshe and 1907water differ significantly in terms of their sourcing, packaging, and water quality. These elements are crucial for consumers when choosing their preferred bottled water brand.

Brand Overview

Refreshe is a widely recognized bottled water brand in the United States, known for its affordability and easy availability in supermarket chains. It targets consumers looking for economical and accessible options.

1907water, on the other hand, is a premium brand sourced from New Zealand's North Island. It is marketed as high-quality water with naturally high alkaline levels, appealing to consumers who prioritize health benefits and superior taste.

Source and Aquifer Information

Refreshe sources its water from various municipal and protected well sources across the United States. This means its water comes from groundwater that is often treated to meet safety standards.

1907water comes exclusively from a deep aquifer in New Zealand, situated in an untouched natural landscape. This aquifer provides naturally alkaline water without the need for additional processing, preserving minerals and ensuring purity.

Water Quality and Purity

Refreshe water is processed to remove impurities and ensure safe drinking standards. It maintains a neutral pH level around 7, which is typical for treated groundwater.

1907water boasts a naturally high pH level of 8.0 to 8.8 due to its unique aquifer source. This high alkalinity contributes to a smoother, crisper taste. Additionally, 1907water is bottled directly at the source, reducing the risk of contamination and preserving its natural mineral content.

By focusing on these critical differences, consumers can better understand which brand aligns more closely with their preferences and values.

Health and Hydration

Both Refreshe and 1907water offer hydration and various health benefits. However, they differ in their mineral content and specific health impacts.

Hydration and Health Benefits

Refreshe provides reliable hydration, offering pure water with no off-tastes. It's convenient and accessible for daily consumption.

1907water aims to hydrate effectively while being packaged in BPA-free recyclable plastic bottles. Its eco-friendly packaging adds a sustainability advantage.

Maintaining optimal hydration is essential for bodily functions, and both brands are formulated to aid in this regard. Refreshe and 1907water ensure they meet basic hydration needs, supporting daily health routines efficiently.

Mineral Content and Health Impact

Refreshe typically offers low mineral content, making it suitable for those who prefer a more neutral taste. It lacks specific enhancements but is generally sufficient for hydration.

1907water contains naturally occurring minerals, contributing to its unique taste and potential health benefits. These minerals may assist in maintaining electrolyte balance and overall well-being.

The mineral content comparison reveals that 1907water might offer additional health perks due to its higher mineral levels. For consumers seeking extra nutrients, 1907water has a slight edge.

Taste Profile

Comparing Refreshe and 1907water reveals distinct differences in flavor due to their unique sources and mineral compositions. These differences may appeal to varied taste preferences among consumers.

Flavor Characteristics

Refreshe is known for its neutral taste, with minimal aftertaste. The water undergoes a thorough purification process, removing impurities and resulting in a clean, straightforward flavor.

1907water hails from New Zealand and is naturally alkaline with a pH of around 8.0. Its slightly alkaline nature gives it a crisp, refreshing quality. The low Total Dissolved Solids (TDS), usually around 80 ppm, contribute to a clean, smooth taste, often perceived as more refined compared to neutral pH waters.

Refreshe Characteristics:

Neutral taste
Minimal aftertaste
Thoroughly purified

1907water Characteristics:

Slightly alkaline (pH 8.0)
Crisp and refreshing
Low TDS (80 ppm)

Taste Test Comparisons

In taste tests, preferences can vary based on the distinctive qualities of each water. Participants often describe Refreshe as unremarkable but consistent, catering to those preferring a no-frills option.

On the other hand, 1907water is frequently praised for its crispness and subtle mineral notes. These attributes make it stand out during blind taste tests, where its smoothness and slightly alkaline profile are often preferred.

Test Outcomes:

Refreshe: Consistent, unobtrusive
1907water: Crisp, refined

These differences in taste can significantly influence consumer choice, depending on individual preferences for neutral versus slightly alkaline profiles.

Production and Bottling Processes

The production and bottling processes for Refreshe and 1907water involve a series of filtration, treatment, and packaging steps designed to ensure high-quality bottled water. Each brand has its unique methods and material choices.

Filtration and Treatment Techniques

Refreshe uses a multi-step filtration process, including reverse osmosis, to eliminate contaminants and impurities. The process starts with basic filtration to remove large particles, followed by activated carbon filters to eliminate chemicals and odors. Finally, reverse osmosis provides a high level of purification, resulting in crisp and clean water.

1907water, on the other hand, is sourced from a natural aquifer in New Zealand. It undergoes minimal filtration, preserving the natural minerals and taste. The treatment primarily includes UV sterilization to ensure microbial safety while maintaining the natural composition of the water. This minimal intervention approach is a key feature that differentiates 1907water from more heavily treated bottled waters.

Bottling and Packaging Differences

Refreshe primarily uses plastic bottles, aiming for lightweight and shatterproof containers. This choice prioritizes convenience and cost-effectiveness. Each bottle is sealed for freshness and features easy-to-open caps, designed for on-the-go hydration. Their packaging includes barcode tracking and batch information, ensuring quality control.

1907water opts for both plastic and glass bottles. The use of glass bottles is particularly noteworthy as it provides a premium packaging option, maintaining the water's purity without any risk of plastic leaching. The glass bottles are recyclable, appealing to environmentally conscious consumers. The plastic bottles used by 1907water are BPA-free, addressing health concerns associated with plastic packaging. Each type of packaging is designed to reflect the premium nature of the product while ensuring the water stays as fresh as possible.

Nutritional and Quality Assessments

In comparing Refreshe and 1907water, it is important to look at their nutritional content and quality measures. Key factors include pH levels, alkalinity, and safety standards.

pH Levels and Alkalinity

Refreshe claims a pH level of 7.4, which is neutral and in line with the natural pH of the human body. This can be ideal for those who want water that closely matches bodily fluids.

1907water, on the other hand, is notable for its alkaline properties. It has a higher pH, typically around 8.0 to 9.0, which some believe can help neutralize acid in the bloodstream and boost metabolism.

Here's a simple table to compare the pH levels:

Brand pH Level Refreshe 7.4 1907water 8.0 - 9.0

Testing and Safety Standards

Both brands adhere to safety standards, but there are distinctions in their quality assurance processes. Refreshe monitors its water for electrolytes and ensures no additives are present. The packaging indicates the absence of sodium, carbohydrates, or proteins, aligned with typical expectations for bottled water.

1907water ensures safety by using BPA-free recyclable plastic. However, the environmental impact of plastic is a concern. Producing these bottles generates CO2 emissions, a factor not directly tied to water quality but affecting overall consumer choice.

Both brands comply with FDA regulations, ensuring that their water is safe for consumption. Regular quality reports and testing protocols are part of their standard practices to maintain consumer trust and ensure health standards are met.

Environmental and Sustainability Considerations

In comparing Refreshe and 1907water, it is essential to assess their environmental footprint and sustainability efforts. Both companies emphasize eco-friendly practices, materials used for bottles, and recycling programs.

Eco-Friendly Practices

1907water has implemented numerous eco-friendly initiatives. The company emphasizes the use of renewable energy sources and minimizes carbon emissions in their production processes. They are committed to water conservation, ensuring minimal impact on local water supplies.

Refreshe also focuses on reducing its environmental impact. They have introduced sustainable sourcing practices and strive to reduce waste throughout their supply chain. They monitor their water extraction processes closely to ensure they do not negatively affect natural ecosystems.

Bottles and Recycling

1907water primarily uses glass bottles, which are highly recyclable and have a lower environmental impact compared to plastic. They also support boxed water alternatives to further reduce plastic waste. Their recycling programs are designed to ensure that a high percentage of their bottles are repurposed.

Refreshe uses plastic bottles but has improved their sustainability by incorporating a significant percentage of recycled plastic in their packaging. They have comprehensive recycling initiatives and actively participate in programs that promote the collection and recycling of plastic bottles.

Both brands are making efforts to address the environmental concerns associated with bottled water, focusing on reducing waste and promoting recycling.

Regulations and Certifications

Refreshe and 1907water must comply with strict standards to ensure safety and quality. These standards are established by regulatory bodies in the U.S. and internationally.

EPA and FDA Compliance

In the United States, bottled water is regulated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), which must meet or exceed standards set by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for tap water. The regulations cover contaminants such as microbes, chemicals, and physical impurities.

The FDA also requires strict labeling requirements, including source identification, and mandates regular testing for contaminants.

Refreshe and 1907water must comply with these regulations to be sold in the U.S.

International Standards

For the global market, bottled water companies might also adhere to standards set by the International Bottled Water Association (IBWA) and other international bodies. These organizations enforce guidelines on water quality, bottling processes, and environmental sustainability.

1907water and Refreshe often participate in these certifications to ensure they meet global quality expectations.

This provides an extra layer of assurance for consumers, indicating that the products align with both local and international safety and quality standards.

Consumer Insights

Refreshe and 1907water cater to different segments of the bottled water market, impacting their market presence and cost structures.

Market Presence and Audience

Refreshe, widely available at grocery chains and convenience stores, focuses on providing budget-friendly hydration options. The brand targets cost-conscious consumers who seek affordable bottled water for daily consumption.

In contrast, 1907water, sourced from New Zealand, emphasizes its naturally alkaline properties. This appeals to health-conscious individuals and premium water consumers. The brand positions itself as a high-quality option, often found in specialty health stores and upscale markets.

Comparative Cost Analysis

Refreshe maintains a competitive pricing strategy, making it a popular choice for consumers seeking affordability. Its cost efficiency plays a significant role in its widespread popularity.

Conversely, 1907water’s premium pricing reflects its unique sourcing and alkaline benefits. Consumers willing to pay a higher price prioritize the perceived health advantages and the exclusive nature of the product.

Both brands present distinct advantages, depending on the consumer's budget and preference for either affordability or premium water features.

Comparison Conclusion

1907water is sourced from New Zealand, known for its naturally alkaline pH of around 7.8 to 8.2. This natural alkalinity supports hydration and overall health. It possesses a crisp and clean taste, with low Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) typically around 80 ppm.

Refreshe, on the other hand, is a popular bottled water brand found in many supermarkets. It is often sourced from various purified municipal supplies, emphasizing consistency and affordability.

Aspect 1907water Refreshe Source New Zealand Municipal Supplies pH Level 7.8 to 8.2 (naturally alkaline) Variable (typically neutral) TDS ~80 ppm Variable Taste Profile Crisp, clean Consistent, neutral

Type of Water:

1907water: Naturally alkaline, sourced directly from natural springs.
Refreshe: Typically purified water from municipal sources.

Bottom Line:

1907water is tailored to those seeking naturally alkaline water with a unique taste.
Refreshe offers an affordable, consistent, and readily available option for everyday hydration.

Refreshe vs. 1907water

A Comparative Analysis of Bottled Water Quality