Smartwater vs. 1907water

Written By Muhammad Shahid

Evaluating the Best Bottled Hydration

Choosing the right bottled water can be a daunting task with so many options available. Two popular choices are Smartwater and 1907water, both of which claim to offer unique benefits. Smartwater is well-known for its added electrolytes and clean, crisp taste, making it a favorite among health enthusiasts and athletes seeking hydration.

1907water, sourced from New Zealand, boasts a naturally alkaline pH of 8.0 and a smooth, refreshing flavor. This high pH level is often associated with better hydration and potential health benefits. When comparing the two, 1907water's natural alkalinity and premium source make it a preferred choice for those seeking high-quality, mineral-rich water.

Whether you prioritize the electrolytes in Smartwater or the natural alkalinity of 1907water, understanding their differences can help you make a more informed decision. Each has its own set of advantages, catering to varied preferences and needs. This comparison aims to highlight what sets them apart and aid in selecting the best option for your lifestyle.

Understanding Bottled Water

Bottled water comes in various forms, each with unique benefits and processes. Hydration, mineral content, and production methods significantly influence the choice between bottled water options.

Hydration and Health Benefits

Bottled water provides a convenient way to stay hydrated, especially for those on the go. Adequate hydration is crucial for maintaining bodily functions, and bottled water ensures that clean, safe drinking water is accessible.

Certain types of bottled water, such as mineral water, contain essential minerals like calcium and magnesium that can benefit health. Smartwater adds electrolytes for taste, while 1907water emphasizes its source purity, impacting its overall mineral composition. The choice of bottled water can depend on individual health needs and preferences.

Types of Bottled Water

Various types of bottled water are available, including spring water, distilled water, filtered water, and alkaline water.

  • Spring water is sourced from natural springs and contains natural minerals.

  • Distilled water undergoes a process that removes impurities and minerals.

  • Filtered water has contaminants removed through filtration systems.

  • Alkaline water has a higher pH level, which some believe can neutralize acid in the body.

1907water is known for its natural mineral content. Smartwater offers both distilled and alkaline varieties, catering to different hydration needs.

Bottled Water Production Processes

The production processes for bottled water vary. Common methods include reverse osmosis, distillation, and natural spring collection.

  • Reverse osmosis removes impurities by forcing water through a semipermeable membrane.

  • Distillation involves boiling water and condensing the steam to remove contaminants.

  • Spring water is collected directly from natural springs, preserving its natural minerals.

Each process impacts the quality and composition of the water. For example, Smartwater uses vapor distillation, ensuring purity, while 1907water prides itself on natural filtration from its source. Understanding these processes can help consumers choose the best water for their needs.

Comparing Smartwater and 1907water

Smartwater and 1907water cater to different preferences with unique attributes, such as Smartwater’s vapor-distillation process and 1907water’s naturally alkaline properties.

Brand Overview

Smartwater is a product of Coca-Cola, renowned for its vapor-distilled purification process. This method replicates the hydrologic cycle, beginning with vaporization and ending with condensation. Post distillation, electrolytes are added to enhance taste.

1907water originates from New Zealand and capitalizes on its naturally alkaline water, which comes from an aquifer that forms from artesian spring water. The brand emphasizes sustainable sourcing and minimal processing to retain the water's natural mineral content.

Product Range

Smartwater offers a variety of products, including the original vapor-distilled water and Smartwater Alkaline. The latter features a higher pH level, which some consumers prefer for the perceived health benefits.

1907water primarily focuses on its naturally alkaline water, available in different sizes. The product maintains a consistent pH of 8.0, making it a favorite for those seeking naturally alkaline hydration without artificial processes. Its packaging also emphasizes environmental friendliness with reusable glass and recyclable plastic options.

Unique Selling Proposition

Smartwater's unique selling point lies in its vapor-distillation, which ensures purity by removing contaminants. The added electrolytes are marketed to boost flavor, attracting those who prefer a clean and crisp taste. The Smartwater Alkaline variant further appeals to a health-conscious audience seeking higher pH water.

1907water's key differentiation is its natural alkalinity. The water's natural pH level of 8.0, derived from untouched aquifers, highlights its purity and minimal processing. This natural approach, combined with sustainable packaging practices, positions 1907water as a premium choice for eco-conscious consumers.

Analyzing Water Quality and Composition

Smartwater and 1907water both aim to offer high-quality hydration, yet their compositions differ in several ways.

pH Levels

Smartwater markets an Alkaline version, boasting a higher pH, while standard Smartwater maintains a neutral pH around 7. In contrast, 1907water is naturally alkaline with a consistent pH level of 7.8, making it slightly more alkaline.

Electrolytes

Smartwater is enhanced with electrolytes. It contains calcium chloride, magnesium chloride, and potassium bicarbonate. These additions are meant to improve taste and hydration. 1907water, being sourced from a natural aquifer, naturally contains essential electrolytes like calcium and magnesium.

Taste

The presence of electrolytes in Smartwater provides a crisp and clean taste. 1907water, with its natural mineral content, offers a slightly different flavor profile, often described as smooth.

Component Smartwater 1907water pH Level Neutral or Alkaline 7.8 (naturally alkaline) Electrolytes Calcium Chloride, Magnesium Chloride, Potassium Bicarbonate Natural Calcium, Magnesium Taste Crisp and Clean Smooth

Purity and Distillation Process

Smartwater undergoes a distillation process aimed at removing impurities, resulting in high purity. The company then adds back electrolytes for taste. 1907water is naturally filtered through geothermal aquifers, preserving its natural purity without additional processing.

Heavy Metals

Both brands are tested to ensure low levels of heavy metals, ensuring consumer safety. Regular quality checks help maintain these standards.

Smartwater and 1907water offer distinct benefits in terms of water quality and composition. Smartwater emphasizes controlled composition and added electrolytes. 1907water offers naturally occurring minerals and a consistent alkaline pH. Both are viable choices depending on consumer preferences for taste and hydration needs.

Health and Nutritional Aspects

This section will compare Smartwater and 1907water based on their content of electrolytes and minerals, effects on hydration and the immune system, and their calories and nutritional information.

Electrolytes and Minerals

Smartwater adds electrolytes like calcium, magnesium, and potassium during its vapor distillation process. These minerals can aid in muscle function and hydration. However, the amounts are often minimal.

1907water boasts natural electrolytes sourced from its artesian water. The levels of these electrolytes tend to be higher, providing benefits such as improved hydration and muscle function.

Both brands emphasize their mineral content but differ in the sources and quantities. Smartwater's added electrolytes might appeal to those needing precise replenishment, while 1907water's natural profile might be suitable for general hydration needs.

Hydration and the Immune System

Smartwater is designed to enhance hydration through the inclusion of electrolytes. This can help with physical activities, especially exercise, by replenishing lost minerals. It's also useful for those susceptible to dehydration due to illness or environmental factors.

1907water, sourced from New Zealand, provides naturally occurring minerals that may support overall hydration. This artesian water is pristine and free from contaminants, appealing to those concerned about water purity.

Both waters aim to support hydration. Smartwater's added minerals are specific, while 1907water offers a natural and holistic approach. Proper hydration can also contribute positively to immune system function.

Calories and Nutrition Facts

Smartwater contains zero calories, no sugars, and no artificial ingredients. It is purely water with added electrolytes, making it suitable for calorie-conscious individuals and those avoiding sugar and allergens.

1907water also has zero calories and no added sugars or artificial ingredients. It is free from common allergens such as gluten and dairy, making it an equally suitable choice for individuals with dietary restrictions.

In essence, both Smartwater and 1907water present themselves as pure, calorie-free hydration options. They cater to health-conscious individuals looking for a clean, refreshing drink without compromising on purity or nutritional quality.

Environmental Concerns

Both Smartwater and 1907water have specific environmental impacts related to the production and disposal of their bottles, as well as the sourcing of their water, which can affect local ecosystems.

Bottle Production and Disposal

Smartwater primarily uses plastic bottles, which are a significant contributor to environmental pollution. These bottles are often made from PET (polyethylene terephthalate) plastic, which requires substantial energy and resources to produce. Despite being recyclable, many end up in landfills or oceans, adding to the growing problem of plastic waste.

1907water offers options in both plastic and glass bottles. While glass bottles are more environmentally friendly as they are reusable and recyclable, they require more energy to produce and transport due to their weight. The use of BPA-free materials in plastic bottles by both brands helps minimize potential health risks, yet the plastic waste issue remains significant.

Water Sourcing and Ecosystem Impact

Smartwater sources its water from local municipal supplies before undergoing vapor distillation. This method is energy-intensive, contributing to its carbon footprint. The increased demand for bottled water can deplete local water resources, impacting the environment and community water availability.

1907water sources its water from the remote Waiwera Artesian Aquifer in New Zealand. While this source is more sustainable, the transportation of bottled water over long distances increases carbon emissions. The impact on local ecosystems can be minimized if sourcing is done responsibly, ensuring the aquifer's health and sustainability.

In conclusion, choosing between Smartwater and 1907water involves weighing the environmental costs of plastic waste, energy use, and water sourcing practices.

Market Presence and Consumer Perception

Smartwater and 1907water are prominent in the bottled water industry, each carving out a unique space. Brand popularity and pricing strategy play key roles in shaping their market presence and consumer perception.

Brand Popularity

Smartwater, a product of Coca-Cola, boasts widespread recognition and market share. Established in the premium bottled water segment, Smartwater leverages Coca-Cola's extensive distribution network.

1907water, sourced from New Zealand, emphasizes its sustainable practices and pristine origin. Though newer to the market, it is gaining traction among environmentally conscious consumers.

Both brands are known for their distinct marketing strategies. Smartwater's sleek and modern branding appeals to urban, health-conscious individuals, whereas 1907water promotes a natural, eco-friendly image.

Comparative Pricing

Smartwater positions itself in the higher price bracket, reflecting its premium status. Average prices for Smartwater range from $1.50 to $2.00 per bottle, depending on size and location.

1907water, also priced as a premium product, shares a similar pricing structure. Its price range can be influenced by its import status and emphasis on sustainability.

Smartwater benefits from Coca-Cola's economies of scale, potentially offering slightly lower prices. 1907water's pricing reflects its commitment to quality and environmental responsibility. Both brands' pricing strategies aim to reinforce their market positioning and appeal to their respective target audiences.

More About Smartwater

More About 1907water

Muhammad Shahid
Previous

Smartwater vs. 7-Select
Next

Skyra vs. Whole Foods 365