Deer Park vs. 1907water

Written By Muhammad Shahid

The Ultimate Bottled Water Comparison

Choosing the right bottled water can be daunting with the plethora of options available. Among the popular choices, Deer Park and 1907water are frequently compared for their distinctive qualities. Deer Park, a well-established brand, prides itself on being 100% natural spring water sourced from various springs along the Eastern Seaboard. Its crisp and clean taste has garnered a loyal following.

In contrast, 1907water is sourced from an aquifer in New Zealand and is known for its high pH level, which many believe offers additional health benefits. The water is marketed for its purity and natural mineral content. When comparing Deer Park with 1907water, the primary factors to consider are the source, taste, and potential health benefits.

For those preferring a locally sourced, refreshing option, Deer Park stands out as an accessible and reliable choice. Meanwhile, 1907water offers a premium experience with its international origin and mineral richness. This article breaks down the characteristics of both brands to help you determine which fits your needs best.

Overview of Deer Park and 1907water

Deer Park and 1907water are two distinct brands in the bottled water industry, each with its own history and unique market position. The comparison highlights their origins and their standing within the market today.

History and Brand Legacy

Deer Park:

Deer Park traces its origins back to just after the American Civil War. Founded in Deer Park, Maryland, it began as a local spring water provider. Over the years, Deer Park expanded its reach, becoming a prominent name along the East Coast of the United States. Acquisitions, including being bought by Nestlé in 1993, have allowed the brand to grow its influence. Its reputation is built on the promise of 100% natural spring water sourced from various springs.

1907water:

1907water is a family-owned company based in Auckland, New Zealand. The brand bottles its water in Paeroa, a small town with a rich history. The company prides itself on local employment and partnerships, contributing to the community’s economic health. With a focus on sustainability and natural purity, 1907water aims to offer high-quality bottled water derived from the North Island's pristine sources.

Current Market Position

Deer Park:

Deer Park maintains a strong presence in the American bottled water market. The brand’s reputation rests on its crisp and refreshing spring water. It has built a loyal customer base along the Eastern Seaboard. The backing of Nestlé has further solidified its presence, enhancing distribution and accessibility. Deer Park's natural spring sources set it apart in a competitive market.

1907water:

1907water has carved out a niche in the international bottled water scene, emphasizing its New Zealand origins and sustainable practices. The brand aims to cater to consumers looking for premium and environmentally conscious products. Despite its smaller scale compared to major global players, 1907water has established trust and recognition through its local ties and commitment to quality. The strategic focus on local sourcing and sustainability resonates with a growing market of eco-conscious consumers.

Source and Purity of Water

When comparing Deer Park and 1907water, understanding their water sources and purification processes is crucial for making an informed choice. Both brands emphasize the natural origins and purity of their waters.

Natural Spring Water Sources

Deer Park sources its water from multiple natural springs across the Eastern seaboard of the United States. These springs are selected to ensure consistent quality and taste. Each spring provides water that has been naturally filtered through various layers of soil and rock.

1907water, on the other hand, is sourced from an artesian aquifer in New Zealand. This aquifer is known for its deep and protected water reserves, ensuring a high level of purity. The water here is naturally alkaline, which some consumers find beneficial for health.

The emphasis on natural spring water sources is a common feature among premium water brands like Evian and Icelandic Glacial, both of which also boast pristine, natural origins.

Purification Processes

Deer Park does not undergo extensive purification because it is marketed as 100% natural spring water. Minor filtration processes are implemented to remove particles, but the water's natural essence is maintained.

1907water prides itself on minimal processing to preserve the natural minerals and alkalinity of the water. This process involves microfiltration to ensure cleanliness while keeping the mineral content intact.

In contrast, brands like Aquafina use more intensive purification methods such as reverse osmosis and UV treatment to ensure purity. This results in water that is free from impurities but also stripped of natural minerals.

The choice between Deer Park and 1907water may come down to consumer preference for natural spring water simplicity vs. purified water's guaranteed cleanliness.

Health and Hydration Benefits

Deer Park and 1907water both offer unique benefits related to health, hydration, minerals, and pH levels, which can influence consumer choice based on individual needs.

Minerals and Electrolytes

Deer Park water is sourced from natural springs along the Eastern Seaboard and contains naturally occurring minerals. These minerals include calcium, magnesium, and potassium, which are essential for maintaining electrolyte balance in the body. These elements help regulate nerve and muscle functions, maintain acid-base balance, and ensure effective hydration.

1907water, originating from New Zealand, is also known for its mineral content. This water includes silica, which supports connective tissue health, alongside calcium and magnesium. Silica can benefit skin, nails, and hair, providing additional health benefits. The balance of electrolytes in 1907water is designed to aid in overall hydration and bodily functions.

Hydration and pH Levels

Deer Park natural spring water has a neutral pH level, which is generally around 7. This neutrality means it is neither too acidic nor too alkaline, making it suitable for most consumers seeking hydration without altering their body's natural pH balance.

On the other hand, 1907water is known for its alkaline nature, with a pH level of around 8. This higher pH level can help neutralize acid in the bloodstream and may assist with acid reflux symptoms. Alkaline water is often sought after by those looking to balance their internal pH and improve overall hydration efficiency.

Both brands offer clean and crisp flavors, ensuring that they not only hydrate effectively but also provide a pleasant drinking experience.

Taste and Flavor Profiles

Deer Park and 1907water are known for their distinctive taste and flavor profiles. By examining natural flavors, additives, and a direct comparison of their flavor profiles, readers can better understand which option suits their palate.

Natural Flavors and Additives

Deer Park sources its water from multiple springs along the Eastern Seaboard. This variety contributes to its crisp and refreshing taste. It is marketed as 100% natural spring water without any additives. The mineral content is subtle, providing a natural taste that reflects its spring sources.

1907water is sourced from an artesian spring in New Zealand. This water is known for its smooth and clean profile, attributed to its natural filtration through ancient volcanic rock. 1907water also claims to be free from additives, relying on the unique minerals present in the spring for flavor.

Comparison of Flavor Profiles

Deer Park has a crisper taste, which some may prefer for its refreshing quality. Its flavor is slightly influenced by the mineral content, offering mild hints of natural minerals.

In contrast, 1907water offers a smooth and velvety taste. The natural minerals present in 1907water create a subtle sweetness that distinguishes it from other waters. Consumers looking for a more refined and delicate flavor might find 1907water more appealing.

In summary, both waters emphasize their natural origins and lack of additives. Deer Park offers crispness, while 1907water provides smoothness and subtle mineral sweetness. Preferences will vary based on individual taste preferences for crisp versus smooth profiles.

Safety and Quality Assurance

Safety and quality assurance are critical when selecting bottled water. Ensuring compliance with FDA regulations and rigorous testing for contaminants helps guarantee that products like Deer Park and 1907water are safe to consume.

FDA Regulations and Compliance

The FDA oversees the bottled water industry. Bottled water, like Deer Park and 1907water, must comply with the FDA's Safe Drinking Water Act regulations. These standards align with those set by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for municipal tap water.

Deer Park and 1907water are regularly monitored to ensure that their production processes meet FDA regulations. This includes testing for contaminants such as lead, chlorine, and fluoride, ensuring these substances remain within permissible limits.

Testing for Contaminants

Regular testing for contaminants ensures the safety of Deer Park and 1907water. Both brands undergo stringent testing protocols to detect and eliminate harmful substances like PFAS chemicals, heavy metals, and other potential toxins.

Deer Park emphasizes its natural spring water sources, while 1907water highlights its artesian aquifer. These sources are tested frequently to ensure that no harmful presence of contaminants is detected. The continuous monitoring and testing help maintain the high safety and quality standards expected from bottled water products.

Environmental and Sustainability Considerations

The environmental impact and sustainability of bottled water brands are crucial factors for many consumers. Key elements include packaging materials and the companies' environmental initiatives.

Packaging and Plastic Use

Deer Park uses 100% recyclable plastic bottles, emphasizing its commitment to sustainability. These bottles are also BPA-free, reducing health risks. Deer Park's packaging includes some recycled materials, aligning with environmental goals.

1907water, hailing from New Zealand, also opts for BPA-free plastic bottles. They distinguish themselves with lower carbon footprint claims. Unlike Deer Park, 1907water focuses on glass bottles, which are recyclable and have less environmental impact.

Corporate Initiatives and Certifications

Deer Park follows guidelines set by the International Bottled Water Association and complies with the Environmental Protection Agency's standards. Their initiatives include water conservation and responsible sourcing from natural springs.

1907water's efforts extend to carbon offset programs and the use of renewable energy in production. They hold certifications from various environmental organizations, showcasing their dedication to sustainability. Their focus on minimal environmental impact reflects in all aspects of their business practices.

Consumer Choices and Considerations

When choosing between Deer Park and 1907water, consumers often base their decision on price, type and variety of water offerings, and availability. Each brand offers unique features that can influence purchasing decisions.

Price Comparisons

Price remains a key factor for many buyers. Deer Park is generally more accessible and often found at competitive prices in grocery stores. The cost per bottle can be relatively lower, providing an economical choice for daily use.

1907water tends to be on the pricier side, partly due to its reputation for high-quality water sourced from New Zealand. Consumers may pay a premium for what is marketed as a more exotic and pure option.

Comparison Table:

Brand Average Price per Bottle (500ml) Deer Park $0.75 1907water $1.50

Type and Variety of Water Offerings

Deer Park offers a range of options, including 100% natural spring water. It's known for its neutral to slightly acidic pH levels. Deer Park also has sparkling water varieties which provide some versatility for consumers.

1907water primarily focuses on artesian water, with claims of naturally high pH levels. It doesn’t typically offer sparkling options, but it promotes its water as naturally alkaline and sourced from a sustainable aquifer.

Types of Water:

  • Deer Park: Spring water, sparkling water

  • 1907water: Artesian water

Availability and Distribution

Deer Park's wide distribution network makes it readily available across the United States. It's commonly found in various grocery stores, convenience stores, and wholesale clubs.

1907water has a more limited yet growing presence, primarily available through specialty stores and online retailers. It is not as ubiquitous as Deer Park but still accessible for consumers looking for premium water options.

Consumers might find Deer Park more convenient for everyday purchase, while 1907water may appeal to those seeking a niche product.

Availability Points:

  • Deer Park: Nationwide in stores and online

  • 1907water: Specialty stores, online

Final Verdict

When comparing Deer Park to 1907water, several factors stand out.

Deer Park sources its water from natural springs across the Eastern Seaboard of the United States. This ensures a consistent, crisp taste that many find refreshing. It's been a trusted name in the industry since 1873, highlighting its long-standing reputation for providing natural spring water.

1907water, on the other hand, comes from the remote areas of New Zealand. The water boasts a smooth taste due to its natural filtration through volcanic rocks, offering a unique and pure drink. The pristine environment contributes to its perceived health benefits and hydration quality.

Taste and Hydration

  • Deer Park:

    • Taste: Crisp and clean

    • Source: Various protected springs

  • 1907water:

    • Taste: Smooth and pure

    • Source: Volcanic rocks in New Zealand

Health Considerations

Both brands offer excellent hydration and health benefits due to their natural sources. Deer Park emphasizes its natural purity and protected environments. 1907water promotes its water as being from a highly pure and untouched source, making it appealing for health-conscious consumers.

Key Differences

  • Origins: Deer Park's American springs vs. 1907water's New Zealand volcanic rocks

  • Taste Profile: Deer Park's crispness vs. 1907water's smoothness

Each brand has its unique features, making them both excellent choices depending on individual taste and preference for origin.

More About Deer Park

More About 1907water

Muhammad Shahid
Previous

Deer Park vs. 7-Select
Next

Dasani vs. Ramona