Ice Mountain vs. 1907water

Written By Muhammad Shahid

Comparing Bottled Water Quality

Choosing the right bottled water can be a decision driven by taste, quality, and source. When it comes to Ice Mountain and 1907water, consumers often wonder which brand stands out. Ice Mountain, sourced from natural springs, prides itself on a multi-step filtration process ensuring purity and clarity. In contrast, 1907water, sourced from a 680-year-old aquifer in New Zealand, promises naturally high pH levels and a refreshing taste.

Ice Mountain offers a crisp and clean taste primarily due to its meticulous filtration process, making it a favorite among spring water enthusiasts. On the other hand, 1907water's unique selling point lies in its alkalinity, which some believe may offer additional health benefits beyond hydration. Each brand has its distinct characteristics that may appeal to different preferences.

When deciding between Ice Mountain and 1907water, it ultimately comes down to the consumer's personal preference for taste and the specific qualities they value in their bottled water. Both brands represent high-quality options in the bottled water market, each with unique attributes that set them apart.

The Basics of Bottled Water

Bottled water comes in various forms, each having distinct characteristics and production methods. It is important to know what differentiates one brand from another.

Understanding Bottled Water

Bottled water is packaged drinking water available for purchase. This category includes various types, such as spring water, purified water, and mineral water.

Spring water, like Ice Mountain and Fiji, is sourced from natural springs and often retains minerals. Purified water, like Aquafina and Dasani, undergoes extensive filtering to remove impurities.

Many bottled waters use specific filtration methods to ensure quality. For example, Smartwater utilizes vapor distillation, while Evian focuses on its natural filtration through glacial sand. Knowing these processes helps in evaluating their benefits and drawbacks.

Different Types of Bottled Water

Spring Water: Derived from natural springs, it retains natural minerals. Ice Mountain and Fiji are popular spring waters. Fiji's water is filtered through volcanic rock, adding unique minerals.

Purified Water: Undergoes processes like distillation, reverse osmosis, or deionization. Aquafina and Dasani are examples. These methods aim to remove contaminants, providing pure water.

Mineral Water: Contains minerals from its source, often contributing to flavor. Evian is a well-known mineral water, sourced from the French Alps. It contains electrolytes like magnesium and calcium.

Artesian Water: Comes from a confined aquifer. This type is less common but still available. For instance, 1907water is sourced from an artesian aquifer in New Zealand, known for its purity.

Each type offers unique quality attributes, tailored to different consumer preferences.

Comparing Ice Mountain and 1907water

Ice Mountain and 1907water each offer distinct characteristics that cater to different consumer preferences. Key differences arise in their brand histories, water sources, and purification processes.

Brand Histories and Values

Ice Mountain is a brand under the Nestlé Waters umbrella, known for its long-standing reputation in the bottled water industry. Established in the early 20th century, Ice Mountain has positioned itself as a reliable provider of natural spring water. The company emphasizes environmental sustainability and community support, implementing various eco-friendly practices.

1907water, on the other hand, originates from New Zealand. This boutique brand prides itself on delivering pure artesian water, sourced from an ancient aquifer. 1907water emphasizes sustainability, using recyclable materials and maintaining ethical sourcing practices. Their mission reflects a commitment to preserving natural resources while providing premium water.

Source and Origin

Ice Mountain sources its water from multiple springs in the Great Lakes region of the United States. These natural springs offer naturally filtered water that passes through layers of rock and soil, contributing to its clean taste. The water is constantly tested to maintain high standards of quality and purity.

1907water is sourced from a pristine artesian aquifer located over 680 feet below the surface in New Zealand. Artesian water is naturally protected from external elements by layers of rock and is known for its high purity. This source provides the water with a distinctive, crisp taste that is unique to its geological origins.

Purification and Filtration Processes

Ice Mountain employs a multi-step purification process to ensure the water's safety and quality. The process includes screening to remove large particles, followed by microfiltration and ozonation. These steps help eliminate any impurities, such as bacteria and organic matter, while maintaining the mineral content that contributes to the water's flavor.

1907water focuses on minimal processing to preserve the natural characteristics of its artesian source. The water undergoes a thorough filtration process to remove particulates, ensuring it remains pure and clean. However, the brand prioritizes maintaining the natural minerals and flavors that are inherent to artesian water, providing a premium, unadulterated drinking experience.

Taste Profiles and Water Quality

Ice Mountain and 1907water each offer unique taste experiences influenced by their mineral content and pH levels. Both brands undergo specific filtration processes to ensure the purity and quality of their water.

Water Composition and Mineral Content

Ice Mountain water is sourced from natural springs and goes through a multi-step filtration process. This process helps maintain its clean, crisp taste by removing large particles and contaminants. The mineral content, including calcium, magnesium, and potassium, adds a subtle mineral taste without overpowering the water's natural flavor.

1907water, sourced from New Zealand, also boasts a natural origin and is known for its smooth and silky mouthfeel. It contains minerals such as silica, calcium, and magnesium, contributing to a balanced and slightly sweet flavor profile. The water's composition enhances its soft texture and refreshing quality.

pH Levels and Their Impact on Taste

Ice Mountain water has a pH level typically ranging from 6.8 to 7.2, which is close to neutral. This pH balance helps maintain a fresh, neutral taste that appeals to a wide range of palates. The near-neutral pH ensures that the water is neither too acidic nor too alkaline, making it smooth and easy to drink.

In contrast, 1907water has a naturally high pH level, usually around 7.8 to 8.0. This alkaline nature gives the water a crisp and invigorating taste. The higher pH level not only contributes to a unique flavor but also provides a refreshing feeling that many consumers find appealing.

By examining these attributes, consumers can better understand the specific taste profiles and quality aspects of Ice Mountain and 1907water.

Health and Hydration

When comparing Ice Mountain and 1907water, it's crucial to consider their health benefits and hydration capabilities. This includes the presence of essential minerals and electrolytes, as well as how effectively each brand supports overall hydration.

Essential Minerals and Electrolytes

Ice Mountain and 1907water offer distinctive mineral profiles. Ice Mountain water is known for its neutral pH and moderate mineral content, including calcium, magnesium, and potassium. These minerals are vital for various bodily functions, such as bone health and muscle function.

1907water, sourced from New Zealand, prides itself on its slightly alkaline pH, ranging from 7.4 to 8.2. This alkalinity can help maintain the body's pH balance and may have additional health benefits. The electrolytes present help in maintaining nerve function and hydration balance.

Hydration Benefits of Bottled Water

Both brands emphasize the importance of hydration. Ice Mountain, being drawn from natural sources, offers a clean and refreshing taste, encouraging adequate water intake, which is essential for maintaining bodily functions.

1907water, with its alkaline properties, claims to provide superior hydration compared to regular bottled water. The presence of electrolytes in 1907water aids in rapid rehydration, making it suitable for those engaged in intense physical activities.

Consistent hydration supports digestive health, joint lubrication, and cognitive function. Both Ice Mountain and 1907water deliver on these fronts, making them excellent choices for maintaining optimal hydration.

Environmental and Safety Considerations

The environmental footprint and safety regulations of Ice Mountain and 1907water are critical aspects when evaluating their impact on health and the planet. Both brands have different approaches to packaging and ensuring water safety.

Packaging and Environmental Footprint

Ice Mountain uses predominantly plastic bottles. Although the bottles are widely recyclable, the actual rate of recycling remains low, leading to environmental concerns. The extraction of petrochemicals to produce these plastics further contributes to the ecological footprint.

1907water opts for eco-friendlier packaging, often using recyclable materials like glass or plant-based plastics. Their commitment to reducing environmental impacts through sustainable practices includes sourcing water from sustainable sources and minimizing the carbon footprint associated with bottle production and transportation.

Safety for both brands adheres to strict regulations set by the FDA and IBWA, ensuring the water undergoes robust filtration processes to remove contaminants. Microplastic contamination remains a concern industry-wide, though both brands strive to maintain high purity standards.

In summary, 1907water's efforts in sustainable packaging better address environmental concerns when compared to Ice Mountain's reliance on plastic.

Consumer Convenience and Lifestyle

Ice Mountain and 1907water offer different advantages for consumers, particularly in terms of accessibility and their roles in lifestyle choices. They differ in how easily consumers can find them and how they fit into a health-conscious lifestyle.

Accessibility and Availability

Ice Mountain is widely available in grocery stores, convenience stores, and online platforms. This makes it easy for consumers to purchase and carry wherever they go. Its universal presence in various retail outlets enhances its convenience for everyday use.

On the other hand, 1907water often appeals to niche markets and might be found more frequently in specialty stores or online. While its accessibility may be more limited compared to Ice Mountain, the brand’s focus on limited distribution can sometimes add a sense of exclusiveness.

Both brands offer delivery services, but Ice Mountain’s extensive retail network often results in higher visibility and easier accessibility for the average consumer. 1907water, although less ubiquitous, has cultivated a loyal following, especially among those who prioritize sustainable and premium water options.

The Role of Brand in Lifestyle Choices

Ice Mountain is associated with reliability and convenience, making it a staple for individuals with busy lifestyles requiring easy access to clean water. It appeals to consumers who prioritize easy-to-find and relatively affordable drinking water options.

1907water positions itself as a premium, eco-friendly choice, often packaged in glass or more sustainable materials. This appeals to health-conscious consumers and those who emphasize environmental sustainability in their lifestyle choices.

The brand image of 1907water often resonates with consumers who look for high-quality, natural products. In contrast, the branding of Ice Mountain is synonymous with dependability and extensive availability, fitting into a variety of lifestyle needs from on-the-go hydration to family consumption at home.

Market and Industry Insights

Ice Mountain and 1907water are key players in the bottled water market, each vying for consumer preference with unique selling points. Their brand presence and commitment to sustainable practices provide insight into their strategies and market positions.

Brand Presence and Consumer Preferences

Ice Mountain, a brand under BlueTriton Brands, is widely recognized for sourcing its water from natural springs in the Midwest. It employs a multi-step filtration process, ensuring purity and quality, which appeals to health-conscious consumers. Ice Mountain's market presence is robust, supported by its history and extensive distribution network in the United States.

1907water, originating from New Zealand, taps into artisanal aquifers for its water. Its premium positioning caters to consumers interested in exclusive and high-quality water options. The brand's emphasis on naturally alkaline water distinguishes it from competitors. Despite being newer to the market than Ice Mountain, 1907water has cultivated a niche following due to its unique source and health benefits.

Sustainable Practices and Eco-Friendly Initiatives

Ice Mountain has increasingly focused on sustainable packaging initiatives. The brand uses recycled PET in its bottles and aims to lessen its environmental impact by encouraging recycling. Its commitment to protecting natural water sources also aligns with broader consumer trends toward eco-friendliness.

1907water leverages eco-friendly packaging and promotes sustainability through its usage of paper-based cartons. The brand highlights its efforts to reduce plastic waste, which resonates with environmentally conscious consumers. Additionally, 1907water’s sourcing from sustainable aquifers emphasizes a minimal environmental footprint from water extraction to packaging.

Both brands’ efforts in sustainability underscore a larger industry trend, where eco-friendly packaging and responsible sourcing are becoming critical differentiators.

Final Considerations and Recommendations

When comparing Ice Mountain and 1907water, several factors come into play.

Quality and Purity: Ice Mountain employs a multi-step filtration process. This ensures contaminants are minimized. 1907water, sourced from New Zealand, is natural artesian water. It boasts a well-regarded purity level without extensive processing.

Taste Preference: Taste can be subjective. Some may prefer the crisp, clean taste of Ice Mountain, while others might lean toward the naturally smooth flavor of 1907water.

Source: Ice Mountain sources its water from multiple springs in Michigan. 1907water comes from a single, protected artesian aquifer in New Zealand. Both locations contribute to the distinct characteristics of each brand.

Cost: Cost varies between the two. Ice Mountain is often more affordable due to its domestic sourcing and widespread availability. 1907water, considered a premium brand, typically comes at a higher price.

| Factors         | Ice Mountain          | 1907water               |
|-----------------|-----------------------|-------------------------|
| Quality/Purity  | Multi-step filtration | Natural artesian source |
| Taste Preference| Clean and crisp       | Smooth and natural      |
| Source          | US Springs            | New Zealand Aquifer     |
| Cost            | Affordable            | Premium pricing         |
Consumers should weigh these aspects to decide which water best fits their needs. Both brands offer safe and reliable hydration options, catering to different tastes and budgets.

More About Ice Mountain

More About 1907water

Muhammad Shahid
Previous

Ice Mountain vs. 7-Select
Next

HFactor vs. Blk